are / were melvins punk?

Started by zium, September 23, 2003, 04:05:12 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 6 Guests are viewing this topic.

Beto Brasil

Quote from: EdStop posing, Beto.

Poser.

ok Ted ,Ed e Fred ! :shock:  :shock:  :shock:
Trading music since 1999 :

Update : http://www.themelvins.net/beto/DVD.htm

adolescent child

hmm i thin 1/3 punk 2/3 metal in music.

cooter

Quote from: HeroinThe Melvins' attitude is totally punk!
Punk = Fuck the world
Jacksonville = most punk song ever

A shot at Fred Durst perhaps??? I hope you kill him Heroin!  :)  :D  :lol:

Beto Brasil

Can someone please kill Fred-shit-Durst?

Quote from: cooter
Quote from: HeroinThe Melvins' attitude is totally punk!
Punk = Fuck the world
Jacksonville = most punk song ever

A shot at Fred Durst perhaps??? I hope you kill him Heroin!  :)  :D  :lol:
Trading music since 1999 :

Update : http://www.themelvins.net/beto/DVD.htm

IRON-MANTIS

IF YOU WERE BORN IN THE LATE 80TIES U DONT KNOW SHIT ABOUT PUNK,THAT MTV SHIT ISNT PUNK ITS POSEN...........PISTOLS BLACK FLAG RAMONES THE LIST GOES ON SOME OF THE BANDS TODAY HAVE THE RIGHT IDEA,BUT WHO WHATS TO BE IN A BAND AND DONT GET PAID IN THE CULTS WE HAVE TODAY.......THATS WHAT KILLED AND HELP PUNK MONEY COMMERICALISM MARKETS.........FUCK OFF

IRON-MANTIS

IF YOU WERE BORN IN THE LATE 80TIES U DONT KNOW SHIT ABOUT PUNK,THAT MTV SHIT ISNT PUNK ITS POSEN...........PISTOLS BLACK FLAG RAMONES THE LIST GOES ON SOME OF THE BANDS TODAY HAVE THE RIGHT IDEA,BUT WHO WHATS TO BE IN A BAND AND DONT GET PAID IN THE CULTS WE HAVE TODAY.......THATS WHAT KILLED AND HELP PUNK MONEY COMMERICALISM MARKETS.........FUCK OFF :twisted:

Ed

Iron-Mantis, you obviously know more about this subject than anyone else on this board.

So, what about Tears For Fears?

turnacuss

OPUNK RAWK IS LIFE AL DIE WHO WATCH MTV.

idiot.

joe preston

Ed, you are a very funny human being, don't ever change.

H-Bomb

The Melvins have a punk influence like Black Flag has a punk influence.  

I would classify it more as a Progessive Punk (oxymoron??) combination with metal, noise and other styles (as noted above).  

So, they aren't punk ala Ramones, Sex Pistols.... but they do fit within the Hardcore community.

Whomever mentioned Zeke was on the right path.

norecess

Progressive punk, that's a good one.

Hey Cloud, this thread might be useful for you.

TGH

The Mangled Demos are so hardcore punk it hurts.
This isn't a time for lectures!

Joe Deutrom

At their start I would say Melvins was a punk band or at least had some songs that can be considered punk. Take "Ever Since My Accident", I am talking about the fast version. Are they a punk band today? I don't think so. They defy discription with each album. Working within the punk genre is very limiting and thats why the Melvins went beyond that.

blacksanta

If punk is NY Dolls metal with the R&B ripped out and played at a faster tempo, then the Melvins began as a punk band. If punk is an attitude that compells one to go against the herd and do things different than the majority, then slowing themselves down and making the slowest, heaviest music possible at a time when heavy music was not popular, than the Melvins out-punked the punks......or something.
Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.

(PAUL)

Eye Flys = most punk song ever.
Hail, not fail.
PS:  fuck him.