PIGS..I just figured it out!!!

Started by anaconda, September 04, 2004, 02:31:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

FartLips

Judy is mad.🤣

Binkard and Friends

whoever compared the Melvins with Queens of the Stone Age..... ugh, im not even gonna say it


as far as the whole Tool influence, i see how they try to achieve some of Tool's atmospheric qualities, but as far as musicianship, songwriting and all that, i dont hear it.

anaconda

Quote from: Binkard and Friendsi see how they try to achieve some of Tool's atmospheric qualities..

That's the best way I've seen it explained! The long quiet parts
evoke that mood in me that I get when I listen to a Tool CD!!
It has that 'atmosphere' to it! The long parts without drums that build
between the heavy cascading riffs, etc.

I'm definitely not talking about Pink Bat or Safety Third. Tool would
never write songs like these.

Dr. Gonzo


anaconda

No. I can't help it if thats what parts of this CD make me think of.
Obviously you seem to disagree. But for the love of god let's not
turn this into a 'tony' type thing. I like you and I hope you like me,
despite the difference of opinion. Otherwise I'll have to take you up
on your offer to meet and have a fist fight!  :lol:

klump

conda isnt saying that the melvins are riipping tool off,  melvins have always sucked in from other bands, mixed it together and made their own version of it...

listen to some brainiac and latin playboys records and then listen to stag...
buzzo is actually singing like the brainiac vocalist on more than one song.

and you can draw paralells on many other things to...

but this is NOT copying, this is emulating and true innovation.
brainiac could never pull Stag off...

anyone with their head outside of their asses understands where im going with this...

collosuss of destiny is melvins version of throbbing gristle and black dice...dont say im wrong cause im not...

theres a bunch of others to :)

just listen, think, and then discover:)

benton netty

Quote from: anacondaNo. I can't help it if thats what parts of this CD make me think of.
Obviously you seem to disagree. But for the love of god let's not
turn this into a 'tony' type thing.

god, will you please shut the fuck up and go listen to a tool album or something?

klump

oh please, dont fuck this thread up to...

benton netty

Quote from: klumpoh please, dont fuck this thread up to...

i'm not the one who brought my name into this discussion, am i? besides, i wasn't talking to you, was i?

klump

hey, i was listening to jimi hendrix with third stone from the sun and it really reminds me of Pigs, and buzz beeing a big hendrix fan (see  "its shoved main riff") i think this is maybe an influence on the album...

say with stupid stoner voice: "No shit, man!"

anti~vermin

Quote from: anacondathe noodly segues on the virus synth

.
does adam do anything with the Virus on the Pigs album?
i havent even heard anything on the cd yet because i am too broke to buy it right now.
but does anyone know exactly what adam does on the new album?
i heard he played some guitar on one song, [the title of which i dont know], and now anaconda says theres some Virus on there too...

i know that on HAT adam used Virus on 'the anti-vermin seed'
and on the Crybaby adam played guitar on 'divorced' [and maybe Virus too?]
colossus of destiny was alot of adam/Virus stuff as well.

surely someone out there knows the specific details and shit... :)

anti~vermin

Quote from: Mr. Stu Pedd Melvins wouldn't try to create anything remotely similar to Tool. Tool is not an influence of theirs to begin with. These are my opinions anyway...

i think that adam and danny are an influence to buzz and probably all of them. maybe maynard too i dont know.
these are important people that we are talking about.
influentially speaking.... yeah
its also obvious to me how ADAM has been influenced by MELVINS.
does anyone else see this as well?

Galvano

Quote from: anti~vermin
Quote from: Mr. Stu Pedd Melvins wouldn't try to create anything remotely similar to Tool. Tool is not an influence of theirs to begin with. These are my opinions anyway...

i think that adam and danny are an influence to buzz and probably all of them. maybe maynard too i dont know.
these are important people that we are talking about.
influentially speaking.... yeah
its also obvious to me how ADAM has been influenced by MELVINS.
does anyone else see this as well?

never

anaconda

antivermin, i'm just speculating the virus part, i'm uncertain exactly
but on the pigs sleeve they credit him with guitar and thank him
for making the introductions to the songs. :P

klump

it doesnt say introductions to the songs, it just say introductions.
i think its becuase it was adam who teamed melvins up with lustmord, capice?
:)