What's the first album a newbie should buy?

Started by Tim1234, April 11, 2005, 11:26:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Tim1234

I was after a compilation of the Melvins to start me off. Is "Melvinmania: The Best of the Atlantic Years 1993-1996" a good starter or are there other better compilations. Or should I start off with some albums. If so which ones?

anaconda


anaconda

but having said that, any self respecting fan will buy all of their albums.
Otherwise you'll miss the unique magic of Honky, Lysol, Prick, the Trilogy etc etc.

Also, the Melvins had nothing to do with the track selection,
promotion or artwork for Melvinmania. It was an Atlantic cash-in.

brian

Quote from: Tim1234I was after a compilation of the Melvins to start me off. Is "Melvinmania: The Best of the Atlantic Years 1993-1996" a good starter or are there other better compilations. Or should I start off with some albums. If so which ones?

i'd buy neither here nor there, you'll have a decent idea of what each album is like then and you'll also have some real cool art.

Alvin

You might want to start off with an album, because I would think starting off with that greatest hits collection would be a little bit confusing and not a good starting point; whereas if you buy Stoner Witch or Houdini (Houdini may be the best starting point) you'll see something better representative of the Melvins and even if that greatest hits things was a cash-in for Atlantic it might be cool to get it later. I may get it at some point actually. I would go for Houdini as a first because it's fairly complex while being accessible even though it's of dark. I guess a lot of Melvins stuff is dark though.

I have Gluey Porch Treatments, Houdini, Prick (not a good starting point), Stoner Witch, and Pigs of the Roman Empire so I don't have a whole lot but I personally think Houdini would probably be a cool starting point.

Bye.


Battlecat

Despite its cash-in status, Melvinmania wouldn't be a bad place to start. It's got a lot of their "classic" songs on it, even if there are some glaring omissions.

As I've said before, the best introduction would be the "Neither Here Nor There" CD, but as it's not available without the book, the price is probably a bit off-putting for a non-obsessive.

Where to start depends to a certain extent on your background. For most people, Houdini or Stoner Witch would be best. Stoner Witch is probably the most accessible and mainstream album they've put out, but could deter those who fear The Metal. If you're coming from a doom/stoner background, then Lysol (aka Melvins) is the way in. Stag's good too - it shows off a lot of different sides of what they do, and is probably their most varied album.

If all that's too confusing: Short answer - Houdini.

Joe Deutrom


blacksanta

1. Prick
2. Singles 1-12
3. Colossus of Destiny
4. Electroretard
5. Never Breathe....
6. Master of Reality
Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.

anaconda

Prick is legit, COD is a bit of a yawner

manstruate

I would personally advise against buying Melvinmania or whatever that thing is called because assuming you end up wanting to buy more, you're just going to buy the three Atlantic albums separately, anyway.  I'd suggest any of the Atlantic albums or maybe The Bootlicker or H.A.T.

AlmightyRetard

I like fucking corpses


Ash

Ya Houdini is a must

The rest is just what you like, each C.D. has it's own style.  The Maggot is amazing, hardcore.  Bootlicker is slow..I bet if you tell everyone some of your favorite bands they would give you your favorite Melvins CDs

Hog log

Quote from: beeeget houdini

agreed

and then get stoner witch