melvins rip off bands

Started by THE DON, June 12, 2005, 11:06:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

zium

that karp singer sounds like the offspring

hmm i just downloaded that dueling banshees song this sounds a lot better (the other song was this one)

Dog Tired

Every band sounds like another band.  It all dates back to when the cavemen recorded rocks banging on rocks on vinyl.

THE DON

dudumumu

anaconda


RichieGoodtimes

One of the greatest records ever made.

zium

downloaded karp - mustache wild yesterday. i listened to it a few times now and i have come to the conclusion that karp is awesome

RichieGoodtimes

I first saw Karp in 1992 or 93. They were kids...hell...I was a kid. Seeing those guys play in a church basement at that time is one of my fondest memories.

I was bummed when they broke up. I always kinda hoped for a reunion, but unfortunatey it's not even possible anymore since Scott died.


I was driving on the freeway at like 4am in this bombed out Charger going like 90 listening to Suplex a couple years ago and I realized at that moment that I would like KARP just as much 25 years from then as I did at that moment.

zach

Karp is great, and Big Business is great too! They just released "Head for the Shallow" on vinyl. (I picked it up from Stonerrock.com's All Thats Heavy store)

All around kick ass band.

Ron Maiden

Karp did fucxking rule. nothing rocks like Bacon Industry.

kinda sounds like "piss of the people, " "Beggin in the streets"
                                                         bacon In  du   stry"


The Whip was fukin sweet. Cant wait for a studio release, there were rumors....

Leroy

Mastadon is kinda  a Melvins ripoff band, but they are awesome.  Very intense drumming goin on there, and a lot of interesting riffs in their music as well.

norecess

Quote from: LeroyMastadon is kinda  a Melvins ripoff band, but they are awesome.  Very intense drumming goin on there, and a lot of interesting riffs in their music as well.

Hell no! Just because their guitar player wears a Melvins shirt all the time doesn't mean they're a ripp off. Ripping a band off or be inspiried by a band are two different things.

Hired Goon

Boris! A Japanese Melvins who not only straight rip them but named themselves after one of Melvins best songs.

Boris: Amplifier Worship

Check this out its fantastic.

klump


rhett E rock

QuoteSo what! The Melvins used to sound like Flipper, Black Flag and the Wipers rolled in joint and smoked by Black Sabbath.

It's hard to hide your influences when you are first starting out.

very well put.  although i'm a little disappointed it took until page two for someone to mention Nirvana.  on another note however...

i don't see the whole point in liking bands that sound too much a like.  just go for the better one and cancel the "not so-good" one out.  i'm a busy man, no time to fuck around (that's why i'm on this message board, hehe).  Karp sounds too much like the Melvins...grant it i heard one album when i was getting my tattoo done, and don't even know which one it is.  so maybe my opinion isn't educated enough.  okay.  i'm done wasting your time.

SonicTruthSyrum

No seriously... listen to the opening bass line of it's shoved and then listen to the guitar riff of the chorus for milk it... fucking so close it hurts...





Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermit
Quote from: the melvinsnirvanas Milk it sounds very much like  It's shoved.

which in turn sounds like the Pixies "Gigantic"....i dont know where you people get these comparisons.  The similarities are so small its not even worth mentioning and its ridiculous to say its a rip-off.  Although the bass part to Its Shoved does sound a hell of a lot like the bass part to "Gigantic."