buzz's comments re: joe preston ep

Started by blipntime, August 03, 2005, 12:27:12 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

blipntime

I cannot believe that Buzz Osbourne said that Joe treated it like a homework assignment and put no effort into it. Buzz's solo EP had only two songs on it! One noise loop, and a fourth song that was done entirely by Dave Grohl (the song appeared on his Pocketwatch demos in completely unaltered form.) Who phoned it in? Joe, who put together a 23 minute opus that obviously would have taken more than an afternoon, plus a really catchy little ditty that was way better than anything Earth ever put out.  One only has to listen to the Thrones' output to decide who is the more artistically adventurous. I like the Melvins and everything, but the way they rag on Joe when he is obviously a very respected musician and has probably influenced the most recent wave of stoner rock more than the Melvins have. They say they haven't even listened to any of his records. They should shut the hell up then.

anaconda

Dont forget that Buzz and Dale are now going to collaborate with
some of Joe's ex band mates from The Whip, namely Big Business.
Joe must have known something after all. Huh Buzz?? Huh??

Kurva

Quote from: anacondaDont forget that Buzz and Dale are now going to collaborate with
some of Joe's ex band mates from The Whip, namely Big Business.
Joe must have known something after all. Huh Buzz?? Huh??

huhhuhuhuhuhuhuhhahahahahahhaha
I hope he reads this :P

Vcavallo

i get the feeling that this poster has some secret intentions.  something about this post is just fishy.  like it is joe or buzz or something.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

___-----_____------_____

Quote from: Vcavallolike it is joe or buzz or something.

I was never too impressed with buzz's ep although I was w/ Joe's.  I still have not heard dales, I need to acquire it.

could heros be watching?
Beauty is a Rare Thing - Ornette Coleman


Michael

I feel the impulse to intervene.  

Buzz's solo album is wonderful in my highly esteemed opinion.  The two "songs" that you are referring to are fantastic works, particularly "Annum", a song that sounds nothing like any other in the Melvins canon.  "Porg" is an experiment that I think he pulled off (I never skip it when listening to the record) and although it's weird that a solo album ends with a song that Buzz doesn't even play on, it seems a bit fitting doesn't it?  Plus, "Skeeter" is one of the best things Dave Grohl has ever done.  If only the Foo Fighters sounded like that.

Joe's record is frankly, a mess.  It is a tedious album and the one record out of all the numerous works with MELVINS written on it that I listen to the least.  Yes, I listen to Prick more often than the Joe Preston EP.  If I am not mistaken, when they reviewed their albums at the time of Stoner Witch's release, Dale stated something to the effect that Joe really did wait until the last minute to throw his together.  He gave it a "big, fat zero".  

Speaking of Mr. Crover, his solo album is the best.  It is the most cohesive and strong of the EP's.

So why quibble?

Dog Tired

No way..... Joe Preston EP the best of the 3, one of the best melvins albums actually, but it's more a thrones album if anything.

It has the 2 weird tracks ala Sperm Whale / White Rabbit EP

and the drone track ala Alarune.

Maybe the Melvins are a bit jealous.


Reverend Ebeneezer

I've said it before and I'll say it again, Buzz's solo EP is dire. Sure, Annum's pretty neat, but the rest of it's blatant filler. In fact, if I remember correctly, Skeeter's a Scream cast-off. Buzz seems somewhat full of it, when discussing the solo records, claiming that he wished that they'd all worked harder on them and then lambasting Joe for being 'lazy'.

Having said that, The Eagle Has Landed on Joe's EP's a waste of three minutes but Bricklebrit and Hands First Flower are awesome songs! In fact, I wrote an article on drone which I sent to a UK metal magazine in which I claimed that Hands First was one of the first examples of the drone-doom genre. Indeed, while I like Dale's to listen to for 3 minute pop songs, Joe's seems the most artistically important.

Now, the reason I think Buzz and Dale spit so much bile in Joe's direction is in part due to whatever reason it was they fired him and partly because, as Buzzo's been quoted as saying, they're sick of people claiming that the Joe Preston era was the best of the Melvins' history. For some reason, Joe's got the same aura as Mike Patton which creates some kind of obsession in his fans and so when Buzz hears that their bassist with the shortest tenure, and little writing input to the band was their most integral member it's likely to rile him.

I doubt this post has anything much to do with the Melvins, past or present, but it's funny that Buzz is linked to Joe again through Big Business.
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

Joe Deutrom

This is the order:

Dale Crover: Crafted, well written tracks.
Joe Preston: Experimental madness.
King Buzzo: Mediocre at best. But it is Buzz so what are you gonna do?

Joe should spend more time working on new Thrones material but I get the feeling he gets lonely.  :D

Buzz and Dale definitely have a chip on their shoulder concerning Joe.

klump


Vcavallo

buzz's has a good sound.

it's amazing how much debate arises over this issue.
REV, i think you are probably right-on about why buzz and dale don't like joe, but i'm not surprised, you are usually quite perceptive and concentrated (or so it seems).  
joe's album, in my opinion, IS experimental, which is something buzz's might not be, but i've been trying lately to decide when experimental is good, and when it is just that: an experiment.  just because he did something different doesn't mean it works.  i don't think there is anything particularly genius about it.  he tried something, it's different, it's boring.  plus 10 points for originality, minus 15 for execution.  
personally, i like buzz's album.  i find it repetitive in a good way, the riffs have a nice groove.  

my final thought (for now):  they all kinda suck.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Vcavallo

Quote from: Reverend Ebeneezer...Buzz seems somewhat full of it...

no news here, eh?  he is a pretty NOTmodest guy.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

GrimReaper

Quote from: Reverend EbeneezerI've said it before and I'll say it again, Buzz's solo EP is dire. Sure, Annum's pretty neat, but the rest of it's blatant filler. In fact, if I remember correctly, Skeeter's a Scream cast-off. Buzz seems somewhat full of it, when discussing the solo records, claiming that he wished that they'd all worked harder on them and then lambasting Joe for being 'lazy'.

Having said that, The Eagle Has Landed on Joe's EP's a waste of three minutes but Bricklebrit and Hands First Flower are awesome songs! In fact, I wrote an article on drone which I sent to a UK metal magazine in which I claimed that Hands First was one of the first examples of the drone-doom genre. Indeed, while I like Dale's to listen to for 3 minute pop songs, Joe's seems the most artistically important.

Now, the reason I think Buzz and Dale spit so much bile in Joe's direction is in part due to whatever reason it was they fired him and partly because, as Buzzo's been quoted as saying, they're sick of people claiming that the Joe Preston era was the best of the Melvins' history. For some reason, Joe's got the same aura as Mike Patton which creates some kind of obsession in his fans and so when Buzz hears that their bassist with the shortest tenure, and little writing input to the band was their most integral member it's likely to rile him.

I doubt this post has anything much to do with the Melvins, past or present, but it's funny that Buzz is linked to Joe again through Big Business.

This is great Rev. You Sir are very articulate. Did your drone article get printed?

blacksanta

I put Buzzo on for Isabella and Annum (one of his best).
I put Preston on for Bricklebrit, if I put it on at all.
The Crover EP is one of the best Melvins releases. It is moody, dark psychedelic drone and I'll be goddamned if Respite isn't one of the heaviest tunes in the Melvins catalog at the proper volume.
Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.