Case study on jello and the melvins [part 1]. PLEASE VOTE

Started by Vcavallo, October 18, 2005, 07:54:42 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

To find out whether or not being a DK fan past or present has any effect on how an individual receives the jelvins album, i'd appreciate it if everyone participated in this.  you too, lurkers.  

i am/was a listener/enjoyer of DK and i like -- strongly like SEIG HOWDY
i am/was a lister/enjoyer of DK and i dislike -- strongly dislike SEIG HOWDY
i am/was a listener/enjoyer of DK and i neither like, nor dislike SEIG HOWDY
i am not/never was a listener/enjoyer of DK and i like -- strongly like SEIG HOWDY
i am not/never was a lister/enjoyer of DK and i dislike -- strongly dislike SEIG HOWDY
i am not/never was a listener of DK and i neither like, nor dislike SEIG HOWDY
i am a melvins fan and past/present listener of DK and i have not listened to the album
i am a melvins fan and not/never have been a listener of DK and haven't listened to the album

Vcavallo

hopefully this will turn out some sort of meaningful data, as long as enough people take it.  many people say, "i used to listen to DK, but that has nothing to do with why i like this album" sure maybe that's true, but i want to see statistics!

thank you for participating
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

norecess

What happens when there are multiple options? E.g.:

- i am/was a listener/enjoyer of DK and i neither like, nor dislike SEIG HOWDY
- i am a melvins fan and past/present listener of DK and i have not bought the album

Oh wait, I know it. It means I'm not buying all my music.

Vcavallo

right, consider "bought the album" to mean "have listened to the album"  i'll change it if i can
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

TOOL

I've said it before & I'll say it again...JELLO SUCKS!
There's a lot of things blamed on me that never happened.  But then, there's a lot of things that I did that I never got caught at.

Green Honey

Quote from: Vcavallo on October 18, 2005, 09:59:37 AM
right, consider "bought the album" to mean "have listened to the album" i'll change it if i can
yeah and do you think you could change the Lyrics thread to Lyrics & Tabs seeing as you moved all my shit i spent the couple of years creating there, and instead of locking the topic whenever you make a decision how about you ask someone else first? nice one, your majesty.

Vcavallo

whoa man, take it easy.  i didn't mean it as some sort of power trip, as you are implying.  it just seemed to make sense.  i thought that section had lyrics and tabs, i forgot it was just filled with brian's lyrics to different albums.   in case you don't check your messages, this is waiting for you in your inbox:

"sorry about moving them, i'll put them back where they were.  it just seemed out of place in the discussion area.  i don't have the option to rename sections (like Melvins Lyrics), i would do it for you if i could.  i didn't lock the post where the notification of the move appeared.  the bbs system automatically writes a little message and subsequently locks the post, i guess it is meant as a notification, not a discussion.  right now it won't let me move it back, but i'll email brian and i'll try again later.
i didn't mean to cause any trouble, it probably would be better off where it was.  it would get more exposure there.

have a good one"

again, i'm sorry if i offended you.  i realize you've been adding to these tabs for years now, and personally i feel it is an invaluable internet resource for the whole melvins-loving-world. no harm intended.

clarification for all:  when posts are moved (for whatever reason) the bbs system automatically locks them.  it isn't some sort of megalomaniacal stunt that us humble moderators pull.  honestly, aside from making this poll a sticky and unjustly moving greenhoney's tabs, i don't think i ever really do much moderating.  this place is pretty tranquil


Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Green Honey

okay sorry if i overreacted there. thanks for explaining. i did think they would be better somewhere else too to be honest, not stuck in the main section. but i don't have the ability to say, create a tabs section...



hint hint

Vcavallo

i too think a tabs section is a great idea. 
i don't blame you for reacting as you did, if i spent hours and hours and hours of the past years tabbing out tons of songs, only to find the information wasn't exactly where i left it, i'd freak out too.  i should have said something to you before fucking with it.  not to beat a dead horse, but when i saw the topic, i thought it was some 1 page tab topic for a few songs, it didn't occur to me at all that it was the same tabs topic that i've seen here since i joined.  so yea, the horse is quite dead, and everything is nice.

Brian, i don't mean to tell you how to run your site at all, but i do have a suggestion: maybe you could include a link to green honey's tabs post in the Melvins Tabs section for the curios web browsers?  i just noticed now that you have all the songs listed, and the ones with available tabs as red links.  that's a nice touch that i hadn't seen till just now.

this thread is so far off topic... :D :shock:
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Pastor Of Muppets

I'm too tired to make sense of this. I'm a huge fan of Melvins and DK and I don't strongly like or strongly dislike Sieg Howdy I just think it's good. Afterall it is only really a few new songs and remixes but I did love Never Breathe. I do like it though just not strongly but I'm all for Melvins working with Jello. Jello with Nomeansno is a great album too. Looking forward to Melvins/Big business.

Vcavallo

pastor, in my complicated poll, i think you'd check "like -- strongly like".
i'm not trying to judge how much people like it, just whether or not they do at all.

for never breathe: http://www.themelvins.net/forum/index.php?topic=4106.0
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

EGO the Living Planet


I'm with Pastor. As suggested I selectedthe "like --- stronglu like" option.

I still think Jello haters are pussies and posuers.

Vcavallo

ego, your username used to make me laugh when i first saw it.

BY THE WAY
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

DubEMC

Quote from: Vcavallo on October 18, 2005, 12:22:37 PM



have a good one"






A good one what? Man V I hate that expression.
Seriously I think you need to add " None Of The Above " to the choices.
I haven't listened to the DKs in years and own nothing by them anymore. I would still enjoy my old favorites if I were to hear them.
This has no bearing in my opinion of Sieg Howdy-I enjoy it for what it is and will continue to find it special since it has become Kevin's last hurrah with the band.
So in conclusion-Have a good day/night/afternoon/evening/rest of your life or whatever. Just don't have a good " one " okay?

Vcavallo

i'll be sure to have a good NIGHT.  thanks.
i don't want to add a "none of the above" because not voting at all would be equivalent.  i'd rather only have pertinent information. besides, how could anyone fit into "none of the above"  if you haven't listened to it, you check either:
"haven't listened, melvins fan only"
or
"haven't listened, melvins and DK fan"

isn't that an adequate catch-all?

in my opinion, from what you wrote, you'd select "like it, is/was a DK listener".  you used to listen to them, and you like the album more than a 50/50 like/dislike.
i don't mean to be rude, but i think it's fine the way it is.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

DubEMC