Case study on jello and the melvins [part 1]. PLEASE VOTE

Started by Vcavallo, October 18, 2005, 07:54:42 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

To find out whether or not being a DK fan past or present has any effect on how an individual receives the jelvins album, i'd appreciate it if everyone participated in this.  you too, lurkers.  

i am/was a listener/enjoyer of DK and i like -- strongly like SEIG HOWDY
i am/was a lister/enjoyer of DK and i dislike -- strongly dislike SEIG HOWDY
i am/was a listener/enjoyer of DK and i neither like, nor dislike SEIG HOWDY
i am not/never was a listener/enjoyer of DK and i like -- strongly like SEIG HOWDY
i am not/never was a lister/enjoyer of DK and i dislike -- strongly dislike SEIG HOWDY
i am not/never was a listener of DK and i neither like, nor dislike SEIG HOWDY
i am a melvins fan and past/present listener of DK and i have not listened to the album
i am a melvins fan and not/never have been a listener of DK and haven't listened to the album

Bitches of Copacabana

Jello and his voice have grown on me quite a bit over the years... I'm a huge Al Jourgensen fan, so Lard basically introduced me to him.
"Be-bop boot and shoe, ding dong the bell has been rang."

klump

after listening to sieg howdy a long time I have to say I think the vocal mix on halo is that way on purpose.

1. Its surprising
2. Its almost the same way Alice cooper mixed the vocals
3. And I think Jello tried to adapt the vocal melody to make it his own sort of speak.

I think this is a good version, it has a good effect.
but it would be cool with Buzz too.

Vcavallo

buzz's voice is just so much more powerful and...throbbing or something. it would fit the song so much better.  jello's voice is good for the type of music he does, but it sounds sorta dinky on such an epic song.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

klump

Quote from: Vcavallo on October 30, 2005, 11:23:59 AM
buzz's voice is just so much more powerful and...throbbing or something. it would fit the song so much better.

klump

I have to point out that I didnt mean "dinky" in a bad way.
gonzo pointed this out to me, a better word to describe it is "jolly".

hope you didnt take this personally gonzo, I know how close you and jello are.  :lol:

Vcavallo

very good points, klump.  when his voice came blasting through it did surprise the shit out of me.  i had the volume pretty loud for the pre-vocal music.  that is a really effective device, and one of the most obvious for the musical artist.  if they want their audience to really think about something, the best way is to blast it out from nowhere and make them turn it down and consider it instead of just letting it pass by.  i don't think the melvins have ever had errors in production this blatent and avoidable. they probably really want to drive the point home.  "we are playing an awesome version of this classic song, and now this: jellow fucking biafra and his jolly as santa voice will come screaming into your ears all off-beat and whatnot.  there's no way you are going to avoid thinking about (not to mention discussing on msessage boards) this fact.  goddamn we are the melvins and we are brillaint!"

goddamn the melvins are brilliant.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

glen

Quote from: Vcavallo on October 30, 2005, 06:32:49 PM

goddamn the melvins are brilliant.
once one gets onboard with this chain of thought, an appreciation of pretty much ANYTHING MELVINS record is easily achievable.  at this point MELVINS could record 45 minutes of instrument tuning and I would probably buy it and after about 3 listens say: "yeah, THAT is the shit."
"Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care." - Richie Goodtimes

Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care.
(signed) MAYNARD  JAMES  KEENAN

GrimReaper


I bought the "Thank you" "Saved Messages" 45 and this falls into your chain of thought.

There is no way this can be considered brilliant. It is just a fun collectable from the 20th anniversary show, increasing in value daily.

glen

hey grim, is "message saved/thank you"  that bad?  I knew it was noise but you make it sound like one of those things you listen to once and never again.
how do you feel about collossus of destiny?
I guess if I had to choose between MELVINS "noise" and MELVINS "music" I would go with the "music" but I appreciate ALOT of the noise stuff, especially when it is created by standard instruments, i.e. guitar/drums/bass.
and another thing: MELVINS take "noise" releases very seriously. Buzz would probably be offended that you said "message saved/thank you" is, in no way, brilliant. not that it matters to ME what you think, you are most definetly entitled to your opinion.  I guess I appreciate some of the noise stuff out of pure respect.  I dunno.
"Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care." - Richie Goodtimes

Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care.
(signed) MAYNARD  JAMES  KEENAN

___-----_____------_____

Quote from: Pastor Of Muppets on October 19, 2005, 04:31:29 AM
Sorry for being the odd one out here but I love Halo Of Flies. I've never heard the Alice Cooper version but I doubt everyone here is a huge Alice Cooper fan and that's the reason they can't handle Jellos voice.
By the way Vcavallo you are a true gent. Thanks so much for the House of Blues concert. It's brilliant. Know where I can get some other Melvins videos or even just their music videos. I've only ever seen Queen and Hooch.

I may be a little late here but, I think the melvin's do the song justice at least musically, I can't say it''s one of the better jello contributions, and something about him doing the song make it weird - I'm not inferring good or bad here just somewhat weird.    For me, nothing will ever stand up to the original, I listened to it just way to many times  when I was like 10 and would stare at the snake on the cover of the killer album and think this is the greatest song I've ever heard, desperado really stood out as well.
Beauty is a Rare Thing - Ornette Coleman


anaconda

that album had one of the best, if not strongest, lineups of all the Alice Cooper releases

glen

cooper hosts a local radio show here in MI.  I am going to have to call up one night and ask him what HE thinks of MELVINS/Jello version. or if he has even heard it for that matter.
I would be curious to know what he thinks of MELVINS in general since they obviously like him.
"Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care." - Richie Goodtimes

Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care.
(signed) MAYNARD  JAMES  KEENAN

humboldt_bear


klump

Quote from: GrimReaper on October 31, 2005, 09:33:22 AM

I bought the "Thank you" "Saved Messages" 45 and this falls into your chain of thought.

There is no way this can be considered brilliant. It is just a fun collectable from the 20th anniversary show, increasing in value daily.


It was funny as hell, hehe.
how much did it cost at the show?

meanclown

Just wanted to mention that those  "adventurous" music fans out there who haven't already experienced the first
Alice Cooper album "Pretties For You" should definitely check it out.......it's brilliant & weird...heck...how many bands can you think of that produced their own debut album?  Zappa, originally slated to produce - as the record was on his "Straight" label - bailed from the sessions after a brief time - legend has it he didn't approve of all the beer & weed the band was indulging in at the time (1969) - haha - anyway - the record is out there, even by Melvins' standards - lots of odd times, bizarre lyrics, noise, etc, and a healthy dose of psychedelia..... I always dreamed that maybe Melvins would cover the entire record someday - that would be a trip....it's the Alice Cooper Group at their freakiest & most experimental. Wonderful stuff..also recommended is "Lay Down & Die, Goodbye"  & "Still No Air" from the second ACG  album "Easy Action" (the album which also features "Return of The Spiders").