Best Melvins bassist

Started by The Stranger, February 16, 2004, 11:58:51 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

anaconda

Of course i love the thrones. we all do,
BUT  i just clued in! YOU ARE JOE!!
you're joe preston! Pleased to meet you chief.

zium

bullhead is my favorite album and i also dig ozma so my vote goes to lorax

Hog log

Quote from: ziumbullhead is my favorite album and i also dig ozma so my vote goes to lorax

I'm with you dude !  8)

The Chalupa


Swagger

Kevin Rutmanis!!!

Although... I like Mark D quite a lot. I think he was the most technically proficient of them all. He also helped open up the Melvins sound. He could really do the melodic thang. I love his stuff on Stoner Witch and Stag. It's brilliant.

But overall I think Kevin is the best match for the band. He's got that great chunky sound which fits the Melvins super. Plus I love the all slide and noise stuff that he dishes out. And yes, he's got stage presence out the wazoo. Three cheers for Kevin.

bUcKsAtAn

Quote from: SwaggerKevin Rutmanis!!!

Although... I like Mark D quite a lot. I think he was the most technically proficient of them all. He also helped open up the Melvins sound. He could really do the melodic thang. I love his stuff on Stoner Witch and Stag. It's brilliant.

But overall I think Kevin is the best match for the band. He's got that great chunky sound which fits the Melvins super. Plus I love the all slide and noise stuff that he dishes out. And yes, he's got stage presence out the wazoo. Three cheers for Kevin.

agreed.

Anonymous

Lorax was heavy and straight! loaded question.

hands down! clean answer...lori. where is she? kevin is a second even though i've never seen him play with them. who else played bass in the melvins?
:mrgreen:

alot more than y'all seem to know about.

Galvano

Mark D

What's so show'ish about Kevin anyway?
All I see him do is standing in one spot, twitching back and forth like it was a spasm or something.

:twisted:

Reverend Ebeneezer

Quote from: GalvanoMark D

What's so show'ish about Kevin anyway?
All I see him do is standing in one spot, twitching back and forth like it was a spasm or something.

:twisted:

Those boxer-shorts'll do it for most people...
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

Beto Brasil

Trading music since 1999 :

Update : http://www.themelvins.net/beto/DVD.htm

the smokey one

well here's my 2 cents.  i can't decide based on which album i like more because it's known that buzz comes up with most of the material.  so my favorite albums are bullhead and eggnog....but lorax really didn't add much.  so i got to give it to kevin, because it takes a really good bass player to play as sloppy as he does, but it's controlled sloppiness.  he brings a looseness to the sound that i like.

doug fisher

Yeah I don't think that Lori or Matt did much writing-wise, but still good and tight bass players.  Mark D and Kevin added some to the writing, as far as I know, but it was still Buzz who controlled the overall direction of the band the most.

Hog log

Quote from: Beto BrasilLori is the Best!
:D

I'm with you dude !

))))((((

After listening to Gift Of Sacrifice (and i've had this thought for ages anyway) i REALLY want Trevor to be the main full-time Melvins bassist. I think he fits into their sound so well. Same goes for live too. Steven always seems like such a nice guy but i've never took to his flamboyant, cookie stage mannerisms and i don't like his singing voice or his Redd Kross pop sensibilities. Songs like 'What's Wrong With You?' aggghh i could do without Melvins making any more songs like that!

In my dream world i've always wished Deutrom or Rutmanis would come back to the band but nowadays i like that they are off exploring their own music. Outside of a song here or there, im not sure it would be right for them to come back to playing bass. And in Mark's case that definitely isn't going to happen anyway.

Pinkus is the only other bassist i like that i would be happy to see with the band permanently. He looks the part and fits in nicely. Bringing some of his banjo playing style to proceedings. Yet i still think Trevor edges it in that he can do the electric and stand-up bass elements. It's funny to me that even though Trevor has never really had a long run in Melvins, to me he still seems much more of a "Melvin" than Steve perhaps ever will. Whenever i see a photo of the band now i just think "oh there's Steve McDonald with the Melvins".

John Schuller

Best Melvins "musicians" which informs their bass playing and therefore makes them the best bass players are a three way tie.

Mark Deutrom - Hell, let's face it, he is also the best Melvins guitarist. Great producer, great composer, best stage presence with the angry cowboy thing. Really understands music and it shows in the songs, albums, and concerts that he was a part of. Plus - he is a really fucking nice guy, I mean super cool. And his album The Blue Bird kills. Mark was part of the second great era of the Melvins (after the Lorax / Joe era).

Steven McDonald - If Gene Simmons and Paul McCartney made a baby it would be Steven McDonald. Really, really great bass player with a history unique to him. I love that his stage mannerisms are so over the top and actually irritates Melvins fans, as a KISS and Redd Kross fan, I am all for it. His bass playing is killer. And did I mention that Steven is also one of the nicest fucking guys in the world?

Trevor Dunn - Mix a virtuoso bass player and a Melvins fan and you get Trevor Dunn. I mean, this guy is deeeeeeeeep, like New York Avant Jazz scene deeeeeeep. And he loves the Melvins. And he loves Kiss. And he can play upright bass and electric bass. Also, a super fucking nice guy.


I also love Kevin (what a fucking weirdo bassist!), Pinkus (another weirdo!), Joe (weirdo!), Jarred (super nice and a weirdo!), Lori (who picks a bass like Lori?).

Matt Lukin was ok at the time.

Most OMINOUS Bass sound goes to Jarred though.