Maggot Vs Bootlicker Vs Crybaby

Started by Pringles, May 27, 2006, 12:00:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Which is the best?

The Maggot
13 (44.8%)
The Bootlicker
15 (51.7%)
The Crybaby
1 (3.4%)

Total Members Voted: 22

Pringles

Bootlicker own the two other hand down.

Nothing can beat Let it all be.
Luck is a residue of design

Joe Deutrom

The Maggot. One of the most brutal Melvins albums.

mopafeena

www.myspace.com/mopafeena
www.myspace.com/afeenaband

Ministry Fiend

Quote from: Pringles on May 27, 2006, 12:00:22 AM
Bootlicker own the two other hand down.

Nothing can beat Let it all be.


Exactley! :cheers:

norecess

Close call, but the Bootlicker wins. Also because I just listened to it.

Metalhead Cow


CaptainPungent


Kessel

Poor Crybaby, he will be crying now.

For life is not happy.

CaptainPungent

I'll hit anyone in the face if they say Crybaby.

heh, kiddin'

blacksanta

The Bootlicker.
The Maggot is a fun metal record, but it felt like the Melvins were trying too hard to prove that they owned all the nu metal fucktards. See How Pretty is a swell drone chant performed by satanic monks lost in the bowels of some long neglected cave. The Green Manalishi is more faithful to the Fleetwood Mac version than Judas Priest's, and it may be Melvins greatest cover. The problem with the album, and why it's never been one of my favorites, is that the songs blend in to one another without enough distinguishing features between them. Thus, the album has a "samey" quality that wears thin on my nerves (as does the annoyingly oppressive production). Yeah, the riffs change, some go fast, some go slow, but rarely do they GO anywhere. Feels like a genre exercise after the experimental trio of Stoner Witch, Stag and Honky.

The Crybaby is also a fun record as well (sometimes). The man With the Laughing Hand is Dead is an underrated classic, sort of a spaghetti western version of They All Must Be Slaughtered. Ramblin' Man is authentic and Shit-kickin' classic country. Some of the songs are just fucking BORING (Divorced, Dry Drunk, Moon Pie). Easy to love, easier to dismiss.

Bootlicker proves that broads and homos can love the Melvins too :wink: Actually, what it proves is that Melvins do not have to be distorted to carry a whole album, and that they could have very well ended up as a fab goth pop band. Sure, there's filler (Wee Wee, Up the Dumper). But on down the hill the treasures come into view. Toy.....the perfect horror movie theme. Let it All Be, dark, menacing, funky, heavy, complex, and it's done QUIETLY. It's a rare band that can pull that off, and it's a masterpiece of understated tension and dread that for the first half has you noddin' yer noggin' like Busta Rhymes is in the house.
Next up, that great Egyptian-innerdesert-gook-blues, black santa. It's psychedelic, rhythmic as the Nile, and goofy as shit. Melvins may have invented a new genre with this one, funnytrippy. (Not excluding Ween, Lips or Surfers of course). Lone Rose Holding Now and Mary Lady Bobby Kins are fast and slow goth pop and sound like Honky outtakes with hooks. Jew Boy Flower Head shows that the Goose Freight Train was not a fluke and that the Melvins can do their own version of blues. And Prig. After annoyingly funny industrial parody, they break into a beautiful acoustic ballad that re-calls the glory days of King Black Acid, Mazzy Star and Slowdive/Mojave 3. The sky is blue, the flower bed your laying in is multi-coloured, and your acid high girlfriend (or boyfriend) is snuggled up next to you. And after a moment of silence, a familier riff starts up, the sky turns black, and she's standing above you with a gun to your skull. "Like 'em. Lick my boots motherfucker."

Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.

Mad Arab

The Maggot. It is unrelenting and in your face.

Tyuge

uh, yeah, what black santa said. Bootlicker all the way! I may be biased towards it more than the rest of the trilogy because i'm a bassist, and kevin's bass just owns it. it's like the melvins' take on "Up on the Sun", except not as bright sounding, because it's... you know. the melvins.