Singing Along to the Melvins Live (?)

Started by alnis, March 18, 2004, 02:27:52 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

alnis

Is it kosher? I don't know if I'd be able to help myself from doing it the whole time. It's always worried me (maybe "always and "worried" are too strong...let's just say I've thought about it before).

On the Portland Show that I just got form STG, there are a few quiet moments when you can hear the whole crowd singing along, and I think it sounds great. It's the first time I've heard it.

What have you guys experienced? Do people sing along?

What do you guys think? Is it fun? Is it annoying? Is it both?

alnis

Upon 30 seconds of reflection, I think my post was pretty dumb.

Well...I guess that if my post was dumb, then I don't want to be smart!

Mario Lemieux

it's been my experience that most people can't even figure out what's going on, let alone sing.  there are a small percentage that do (sing), though.

deadstone75

why not sing? i mean, who the hell cares, anyway?

they stopped throwing people out for singing at melvins shows in 1997, so you have no worries.

klump

I TOTALLY disagree! this is what lynching should be used for!...just kidding...Im probably never gonna see the melvins again :( you damn americans!!!!

Reverend Ebeneezer

When they played "The B'oat" the band actually went silent for the line "Give me 46, give me 45". The crowd roared...I'd say go with it...I couldn't help it either...
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

Anonymous

I can't help singing along. It amazed me how much of the crowd in Portland were screaming out the end of With Teeth.
Blacksanta

flyinghouses

.  :D
(.)(.)
   

/(())\

Dave

Audience participation of that nature is what it's all about man, go for it.


To this day the best show I've ever been to was Rush, simply because the connection between the audience and band was so rich. Singing along was a big part of that connection.


I think nothing could be more rewarding, more energizing, more magical to an artist during a live show than to receive that kind of appreciation and connection with an audience.


Sing on Big Daddy, Sing ON


Unfortunately I've only seen the Melvins once, when they opened for Tool, so I've yet to see what kind of atmosphere exists at one of their "real" shows. Hopefully it's not a bunch of degenerates white power stomping, punching each other, and spilling beer...
"There is no exquisite beauty without some strangeness in the proportion."

- Lord Verulam

Jamie


Dave

Quote from: JamieHAHHAHAHAHAH

you saw Rush!!!!! :D

Jealous?
"There is no exquisite beauty without some strangeness in the proportion."

- Lord Verulam

gwiz

Y'know sometimes you cant not sing cos it feels good.
Its when drunk yobbos sort of yell the songs that pisses me off.
When i saw Melvins most ppl probaly only heard of them so didnt really know the songs. But when i saw korn that was another story. Middle of the crowd and every muthafucker was screaming. Honestly i couldnt hear Jonathans singing at all. That pissed me off and i was also really dissapointed.
So i guess the conclusion is sing if you want to but dont be an asshole about it.