Singles 1-12 -- It's Shoved

[petersm6449]

I was digging through some Melvins stuff and looking up some details in the Wiki.  On the Singles 1-12 album page ( http://www.themelvins.net/wiki/index.php?title=Singles_1-12 ), the note for "It's Shoved" states "We think it's live but it might be rehearsal/keg party."  To my ears this sounds like the same recording as the live version on the Lizzy single.  The Lizzy CD Single page ( http://www.themelvins.net/wiki/index.php?title=Lizzy_%28single%29 ) states that the track was "Recorded live at Yo Yo Studios by Pat Maley at the Capital Theatre Olympia, WA February 12, 1993."

Does anybody agree?  Should the note on the Singles 1-12 album page be updated?

[anaconda]

Different track lengths. One is 3:11, the other is 3:16

is that too nit-picky?

[petersm6449]

I just think it's from the same recording of the same live performance in both cases.

[anaconda]

I agree, but technically different because of the incongruous song lengths.

again, too-nitpicky??

[Uncle Fester]

I agree, but technically different because of the incongruous song lengths.

again, too-nitpicky??

i noticed in that song that whoever is playing bass screws up and stops playing for a measure or something and then joins back in.
i mean on the singles 1-12 version