Buzz makes Spins list of Top 100 Guitarists!

Started by GrimReaper, May 03, 2012, 09:37:36 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

FartLips

Quote from: DC (the dickman) Hart on May 04, 2012, 10:20:16 PM
I wholly endorse any list that omits hendrix, because guitarists are assholes and I hope this pisses them off :P
lets not forget, you're a guitarist too, asshole. :lol:

never was a fan of that trippy hippy fuck anyways. :P
Judy is mad.🤣

tinnitus photo

there's obviously some pandering and self-consciousness around this list, and some stunts (ie, putting Skrillex on the lead-in page) but there are some really good choices too.

i thought it was refreshing not to have a classic rock rehash of the old standards, and instead get some real breadth to some of the selections. i would have never thought to see names like Greg Sage, Keiji Haino, Eugene Chadbourne, etc.

i guess it also helps that this list had a lot of overlap w/ my musical tastes...i've seen and/or own recordings from 71 of the mentioned names.

Hortense

Quote from: Chief Ten Beers on May 04, 2012, 05:27:03 PM
Doesn't a different mag do this crap every year? :?

If you see a list and Frank Zappa and Robert Fripp aren't #s 1 & 2, then it's a total piece of shit.

I sort of tend to agree with this statement though I would also note that this SPIN list has Adrian Belew in the seventies with Billy Corgan ahead of that.  It's that kind of blundering foolery that I can't fathom.  Where is Billy Gibbons?  Where is Michael Bruce?  Why no whatshisname (John Reis?) from Drive Like Jehu/Hot Snakes?  This is supposed to be an underground-y-ish sort of list, no?

Nevertheless, there are good players on this thing as someone noted above.  Despite all my griping I DO appreciate the very necessary inclusion of good ole Buzz.

WGB

No Ginger wildheart or Poison Ivy either.

Captain CoryCory

When you really think about it, hipsters or Rolling Stone douchebags or whatever... If it wasn't for Les Paul making the electric guitar AND the four-track we wouldn't have any of this. Try picturing Sabbath or the Beatles or Lady Gaga or Nickelback on a 2-track tape recorder...

So LES PAUL FOR NUMBER ONE.

homeless_dad

D. Boon was an excellent pick and always over looked.
Is Ian back yet??

FartLips

Judy is mad.🤣

EGO the Living Planet


If the title had been "100 Most Underrated Guitarists" I'd be all for it with no reservations. Given that they explicitly were looking to avoid all the usual names I think it's well done. Yeah there's a few I think they missed (Paul Leary and Poison Ivy are good examples) but plenty of generally overlooked players (D. Boon! Curt Kirkwood! Zoot Horn Rollo!) are getting some attention they usually don't. 

I get the point they were making about Jam Master Jay and Skillerix essentially creating guitar riffs with turntables/samples and riffs being the heart of what makes a great player but I think putting them both on the list is a bit much.

I think Cobain is terribly underrated as a guitar player (an opinion that I believe Buzz shares - not that this matters). I'm glad to see him on the list.

black stallion

Quote from: EGO the Living Planet on May 11, 2012, 09:22:40 AM



I think Cobain is terribly underrated as a guitar player (an opinion that I believe Buzz shares - not that this matters). I'm glad to see him on the list.

some guitar parts on Bleach were not a joke
Charmicarmicat:Bastards

(((O)))

I like Cobain's style. Nothing technical, but it hits the spot!

Greasy Statement

at least they acknowledged rowland howard, but omitting geordie walker was silly...
but skrillex? hipster please....

homeless_dad

Quote from: black stallion on May 11, 2012, 09:31:29 AM
Quote from: EGO the Living Planet on May 11, 2012, 09:22:40 AM



I think Cobain is terribly underrated as a guitar player (an opinion that I believe Buzz shares - not that this matters). I'm glad to see him on the list.

some guitar parts on Bleach were not a joke
I still can't figure out how to play the swap meet riff.
Is Ian back yet??

homeless_dad

And serve the servants has one of my favorite guitar solos.  At a point during it he sounds like he's mocking his own guitar solo.  It's the brilliance of Cobain.
Is Ian back yet??

(((O)))

Quote from: homeless_dad on May 11, 2012, 09:51:38 AM
And serve the servants has one of my favorite guitar solos.  At a point during it he sounds like he's mocking his own guitar solo.  It's the brilliance of Cobain.
Oh yes that's very true actually. I think i would describe his guitar playing as sort of "snakey" if you know what i mean there? It doesn't seem very structured, more open ended a bit like Sonic Youth do. Very atonal also. He plays some great stuff on In Utero. Almost casual and half assed yet still rockin'.

homeless_dad

Quote from: )))((( on May 11, 2012, 09:55:39 AM
Quote from: homeless_dad on May 11, 2012, 09:51:38 AM
And serve the servants has one of my favorite guitar solos.  At a point during it he sounds like he's mocking his own guitar solo.  It's the brilliance of Cobain.
Oh yes that's very true actually. I think i would describe his guitar playing as sort of "snakey" if you know what i mean there? It doesn't seem very structured, more open ended a bit like Sonic Youth do. Very atonal also. He plays some great stuff on In Utero. Almost casual and half assed yet still rockin'.
Snakey.  Ha!  Yep, his opinions on the state of rock 'n' roll (both then and now) can be whittled down to that "snakey" solo. 

In utero is my favorite of theirs for 'radio friendly unit shifter' alone.
Is Ian back yet??