pigs of the roman empire reviews thread

Started by benton netty, August 30, 2004, 08:55:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Galvano

And how about that Cows site Klump??   :cheers:

klump

im almost done, but dont talk ab
out that here! youll end up in victimsville!


Vcavallo

Quote from: steve... remember that we get two Melvins releases this year... one experimental and one (I hope) of pure music.  :)

but don't forget they are both collaborations..so it counts more like less than one real one
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Dr. Gonzo

Cows are one of my favourite bands..... When is the next Heroine Sheiks due!?

EDIT: New Update From Shannon

The Heroine Sheiks are doing a nation-wide tour this fall, starting in LATE SEPTEMBER. Details coming soon, but we are finally touring the SOUTH. The southern leg of the tour will be with GIBBY HAYNES' new band, GIBBY HAYNES AND HIS PROBLEM. What? Your gonna miss THAT?

Of course there has some speculation for a long time as to what Gibby's problem is. He said he would tell me - if I lent him some money. No sweat. So, his problem is that HE LOSES HIS CAR KEYS A LOT. I've got the same problem with TWENTY DOLLAR BILLS. Oh yeah, and HARD NARCOTICS.

WE LIKE 'EM. I checked out a band a few weeks ago called THE DIRTY BOMS. Have you ever seen one of those paintings done by and elephant? That's what these guys sound like. I asked the singer, FELIX, if he didn't think the name sounded an awful lot like THE DIRT BOMBS? He said, "You know, I suppose it does."

-Shannon


That's pretty funny... Shannon's always losing his Hard Narcotics
I hear Gibby Haynes Problem fucking sucks. BHS fans walk out of the concerts and say the album is fucking terrible. But I'm still interested.

benton netty

dude, someone call the thread police. dr. gonzo's gone off the rails completely. :lol:

FartLips

Quote from: Dr. GonzoCows are one of my favourite bands..... When is the next Heroine Sheiks due!?

EDIT: New Update From Shannon

The Heroine Sheiks are doing a nation-wide tour this fall, starting in LATE SEPTEMBER. Details coming soon, but we are finally touring the SOUTH. The southern leg of the tour will be with GIBBY HAYNES' new band, GIBBY HAYNES AND HIS PROBLEM. What? Your gonna miss THAT?

Of course there has some speculation for a long time as to what Gibby's problem is. He said he would tell me - if I lent him some money. No sweat. So, his problem is that HE LOSES HIS CAR KEYS A LOT. I've got the same problem with TWENTY DOLLAR BILLS. Oh yeah, and HARD NARCOTICS.

WE LIKE 'EM. I checked out a band a few weeks ago called THE DIRTY BOMS. Have you ever seen one of those paintings done by and elephant? That's what these guys sound like. I asked the singer, FELIX, if he didn't think the name sounded an awful lot like THE DIRT BOMBS? He said, "You know, I suppose it does."

-Shannon


That's pretty funny... Shannon's always losing his Hard Narcotics
I hear Gibby Haynes Problem fucking sucks. BHS fans walk out of the concerts and say the album is fucking terrible. But I'm still interested.
this is the best review yet! :D
Judy is mad.🤣

(PAUL)

I heard a track from the Gibby Haynes solo album, and it was awful. Let's see, ah, here it is:
http://www.surfdog.com/music/gibby/kaiser.mp3

And don't forget the Melvins released the book this year! That's like the coolest book I own (although I don't own many art books).
Hail, not fail.
PS:  fuck him.

blacksanta

This one comes from C. Troutman over at Stonerrock.com:





The Melvins. That name alone can be the deciding factor lately on whether it's a 'must have' or a 'must skip' album. I personally am a huge Melvins fan, but some of the so called 'noise' albums can be disappointing to say the least. They do their own thing. Plain and simple. No one can change the fact that 'Colosses Of Destiny' was one of the most disappointing albums for me to purchase, but I was immediately back for more with the records which followed. I have seen the writing styles morph from flat out punk rock to some heavy ass metal, as have most that have stayed put with this band through the years.

This album will consume you with it's opening track, 'III' as it's what the band has been more than capable of doing for years, and that's pummeling ones' ass. A standout track, will consume you and remind you of the first time you heard The Melvins, in which you may have decided : "This is some fucking heavy shit..."

The further descent into the darker ambient sounds which Lustmord brings to the table, shows the direction that the Melvins are not afraid to venture into. Mesmorizing. Dark.Trippy.Heavy.

Atmospheres quickly evaporate into some of the heavy familar Melvinesque sound we have all come to know and love alongside some unique approaches to experimental jams. Songs structures are prevalent as this isn't a 'noise' album, in one sense, as it is in another. 'Toadi Accerrato' delves into Pattonistic experimental beats reminiscent of a Melvins/Tomahawk jam. An epic masterpiece, the title track ' Pigs Of The Roman Empire' may be one of their strongest songs written to date. Osbourne has found quite the riff in which to take the opening trancelike intro and transform into a truly epic mindblowing experience. This 22 minute 'ride' through some of the trippiest trance may be the deciding factor in how you rate this album. For me, well, it was the dark undertones that I havent seen much from them in their past material that left them leaving an almost doomlike mark on me. Electronic fan I am not, but this works. It lays the groundwork for the crushing that follows. I am not afraid to say there may be some of the strongest songs they've done to this point on this release, and that is spanning alot of material.

I have to hand it to the Melvins for not being afraid to take it one step further and unload one of the most intriguing and heavy albums I've heard in quite some time. File with your experimental/ambient/drone albums...and put it right up front. This may be the masterpiece we thought we already got from them.



Maximum volume yields maximum goats..
Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.

Dr. Gonzo

funny... because every review posted on stonerrock.com is positive.
They put those there so the albums will sell.

EDIT: DUDE I heard Kaiser on the radio and thought it was pretty fucking cool. I had no idea it was Gibby. Geezes I'm an idiot. Awesome POP song.

Jess

good review.

and gonzo,  Come On......come on.........











i watch too much south park

steve

After a few more listens...

"Pigs" may be one of the best songs I have ever heard. I was first annoyed by the volume changes near the end but it all works for me...
...Steve

Chomas

"They put those there so the albums will sell"

I seriously doubt it

Joe Deutrom

Quote from: blacksantaThis one comes from C. Troutman over at Stonerrock.com:





The Melvins. That name alone can be the deciding factor lately on whether it's a 'must have' or a 'must skip' album. I personally am a huge Melvins fan, but some of the so called 'noise' albums can be disappointing to say the least. They do their own thing. Plain and simple. No one can change the fact that 'Colosses Of Destiny' was one of the most disappointing albums for me to purchase, but I was immediately back for more with the records which followed. I have seen the writing styles morph from flat out punk rock to some heavy ass metal, as have most that have stayed put with this band through the years.

This album will consume you with it's opening track, 'III' as it's what the band has been more than capable of doing for years, and that's pummeling ones' ass. A standout track, will consume you and remind you of the first time you heard The Melvins, in which you may have decided : "This is some fucking heavy shit..."

The further descent into the darker ambient sounds which Lustmord brings to the table, shows the direction that the Melvins are not afraid to venture into. Mesmorizing. Dark.Trippy.Heavy.

Atmospheres quickly evaporate into some of the heavy familar Melvinesque sound we have all come to know and love alongside some unique approaches to experimental jams. Songs structures are prevalent as this isn't a 'noise' album, in one sense, as it is in another. 'Toadi Accerrato' delves into Pattonistic experimental beats reminiscent of a Melvins/Tomahawk jam. An epic masterpiece, the title track ' Pigs Of The Roman Empire' may be one of their strongest songs written to date. Osbourne has found quite the riff in which to take the opening trancelike intro and transform into a truly epic mindblowing experience. This 22 minute 'ride' through some of the trippiest trance may be the deciding factor in how you rate this album. For me, well, it was the dark undertones that I havent seen much from them in their past material that left them leaving an almost doomlike mark on me. Electronic fan I am not, but this works. It lays the groundwork for the crushing that follows. I am not afraid to say there may be some of the strongest songs they've done to this point on this release, and that is spanning alot of material.

I have to hand it to the Melvins for not being afraid to take it one step further and unload one of the most intriguing and heavy albums I've heard in quite some time. File with your experimental/ambient/drone albums...and put it right up front. This may be the masterpiece we thought we already got from them.



Maximum volume yields maximum goats..

Why don't the lot of you just stick with Houdini. How can you guys say this new album is no good? I think some of you may have an undiagnosed case of the mythical ADD. These tracks build up layer after layer and I guess this is whats wrong with it in your all's view. I agree with this review of POTRE, but his opinion of Collossus Of Destiny being a disappointment is off. What about the crushing live version of Eyes Flys? Doesn't this song redeem the album from being called a disappointment?  I liked COD because I can appreciate experimental noisescapes. I say more people like POTRE than those who do not. A great thing about the Melvins is that after 20 yrs, they can still inspire great discussion and differing opinions when they put out material. Its amazing when you get right down to it. Tell me about any other active band right now who can do this. The Rolling Stones? HA HA.

Dr. Gonzo

It's true you idiot!
It's a store, every review is positive.
They're not gonna put bad reviews next to an album they're trying to sell.

Just go ahead and check every album on the site. Not one negative review.