buzz's comments re: joe preston ep

Started by blipntime, August 03, 2005, 12:27:12 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Reverend Ebeneezer

Quote from: Vcavallojoe's album, in my opinion, IS experimental, which is something buzz's might not be, but i've been trying lately to decide when experimental is good, and when it is just that: an experiment.  just because he did something different doesn't mean it works.  i don't think there is anything particularly genius about it.  he tried something, it's different, it's boring.  plus 10 points for originality, minus 15 for execution.  
.

Oh, yeah, experimentation doesn't automatically equal 'good'. I mean, personally, I see very little merit or artistic vision in things like Merzbow (I've heard Venerealogy or whatever it's called) but Joe's drone track predates Earth 2 by about a year, and like it or not, it's a release that's influenced a lot of people. I mean, I dig it but I can understand why some wouldn't. Like Collossus in that respect, I guess...

And Grimmy, I've not heard back from the mag but I'll let you know if I hear that it's going to be published. Thanks for the compliment, too, bud.
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

DubEMC

Anyone else get the feeling that POTRE was the Melvins trying to do a Thrones album?

popeye

...that first post prob'ly was Buzzo - and that's as close as he'll ever come to apologizing for Anything....

lord of heaviness

Quote from: anacondaDont forget that Buzz and Dale are now going to collaborate with
some of Joe's ex band mates from The Whip, namely Big Business.
Joe must have known something after all. Huh Buzz?? Huh??

i do find this very interesting, indeed.
What do you think you're looking at, sugar tits?

cellphone

I think I listened to joe's once and wasn't really impressed.  buzz's is okay for a few listens, but dale's is definitely the best.

Joe Deutrom

Quote from: Vcavalloi get the feeling that this poster has some secret intentions.  something about this post is just fishy.  like it is joe or buzz or something.

Hey Scooby!

turnacus

isabella > better than anything joe preston, dale, or even jonas salk could conjure up.

BUt thats mostly to daves credito.
Van Hagar

blipntime

Quote from: Reverend Ebeneezer
Now, the reason I think Buzz and Dale spit so much bile in Joe's direction is in part due to whatever reason it was they fired him and partly because, as Buzzo's been quoted as saying, they're sick of people claiming that the Joe Preston era was the best of the Melvins' history. For some reason, Joe's got the same aura as Mike Patton which creates some kind of obsession in his fans and so when Buzz hears that their bassist with the shortest tenure, and little writing input to the band was their most integral member it's likely to rile him.

OBVIOUSLY from examining his career, despite naysayers, he has more integrity than just about anyone. Until Southern Lord came out with a Thrones shirt, he only sold them at his own shows. And from posts, I've gleaned Joe was not even aware of the Southern Lord t-shirt. I got a Thrones show booked here, then his van broke down and he cancelled, then he made it here the next year but I missed it, so it kind of sucks I've never seen them...but he has defined the genre. Is it a coincidence that Hung Bunny/Roman Bird Dog has Thrones written all over it, and it could quite possibly be considered the Melvins' finest moment?

I am a big Thrones fan ever since I heard Alraune in 97. I also picked up the Senex single around this point in time. I had White Rabbit on vinyl and a couple of other singles...but if I could hear the Punk In My Vitamins cassettes I'd flip. Of course he's not releasing them on CD despite the obvious monetary gain. Probably not much but up until the High On Fire gig, I believe he was working in a warehouse, so it probably wouldn't hurt.

The fact that Joe does it all by himself, at home, for himself, and lets us hear the amazing results is every artists' dream. Now the Melvins do have the luxury of releasing a lot of material. But what are they doing? Regurgitating shitty demos from 20 years ago instead of writing anything new. At least release a remastered Ozma and Bullhead since the former has some of the shittiest production this side of early COC records, and the latter, despite being the most kick ass Melvins record, is also one of the quietest albums I have ever heard.

Anyway---it just seems like the Melvins revel in assholes of rock status whereas Joe is just a regular guy. It sort of epitomizes the whole Stoner Rock thing---and its not just dumb wizards or songs about weed. It captures the Pink Floyd lurking behind the Black Sabbath vibe of stoner rock---but its just a completely new entity musically.

Anyway I'm rambling, but the Thrones are the most important thing musically since I graduated high school and that was 10 years ago.

blipntime

Oh yeah---since no one has mentioned it, at some point in San Fran Joe invited someone back to the Melvins practice pad to show it off, because I guess Joe was young and his dream had always been to play with the Melvins. So I guess once this guy found out where the place was he came back later, broke in and stole some of their stuff, and thats why they booted Joe. Kinda shitty. But man wasnt the shit insured?

Anyway, I saw some other folks from OKC on here---hit me up we'll get together and do something , especially if yer musicians.

Grungeisdead

JOE solo lp yet another rip off of a nirvana thing, the eagle has landed was a running joke by nirvana and bootleggers.

And then you've got lysol, a bleach product. Nirvana had a album out called bleach ya before melvins.

Wait what am I talking about? .

THE DON

Quote from: GrungeisdeadJOE solo lp yet another rip off of a nirvana thing, the eagle has landed was a running joke by nirvana and bootleggers.

And then you've got lysol, a bleach product. Nirvana had a album out called bleach ya before melvins.

Wait what am I talking about? .

huh?
dudumumu

Joe Deutrom

Roman Bird Dog is one Melvins song I can say without a doubt is one of my favorites. Thrones is a product of genius and originality. Welcome to the board blipntime. Your post is the first one I have read that had a specific reason why Joe was kicked out. It seems strange that they kicked Joe out for this, if this is the truth. It wasn't Joe's fault. It would be an angry situation definitely though, since the Melvins aren't made of money and professional gear isn't cheap.

cellphone

Quote from: blipntime
The fact that Joe does it all by himself, at home, for himself, and lets us hear the amazing results is every artists' dream. Now the Melvins do have the luxury of releasing a lot of material. But what are they doing? Regurgitating shitty demos from 20 years ago instead of writing anything new. At least release a remastered Ozma and Bullhead since the former has some of the shittiest production this side of early COC records, and the latter, despite being the most kick ass Melvins record, is also one of the quietest albums I have ever heard.

I think the biggest misconception a person can have about any band is that they owe them something.  This isn't defending a release schedule that isn't ideal for the fanbase.  Far from it.  I'd rather have two genuine Melvins album a month and a weekly visit from Dale's wife ( :roll: ). What I mean is that everyone seems to have this thing in their head that because they pay attention to some band and buy their albums, they are owed a product tailored to their individual preference.

The truth is, you're wrong.  Look at this: -------> $$$$$$$

Vcavallo

blip, your post really made me think about the whole situation in a different light.  even the melvins.  thanks for such a perfect translation of very poignant thoughts.  
and yea, i second that other post there, thanks for producing a solid reason of why joe was kicked out.  

now, as i said before.  this poster is either joe or buzz.  i've made my decision, and it is obviously joe.

sorry that was a stupid joke.  really, welcome.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

anaconda

whoever it is theyre randomizing their IP, vin youre privvy to this, click  on the IP button and have a look as well :P