Do you guyes think...

Started by chopklop, August 09, 2005, 02:52:49 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

chopklop

I think Buzz's involvment in Fantomas really influenced his approach to the Melvins stuff. I think the trilogy was right on the heels of the first Fantomas and maybe only the Bootlicker has that ambient Fantomas vibe, but I think looking at HAT and POTRE it is obvious. They started using keyboards and shit on the first (HAT), but Pigs I think it is definitely obvious, it's pretty much a soundtrack Melvins style. Anyway, just a theory-let me know what yall think.

Vcavallo

i'll definitely agree that it is like a soundtrack.  partly because buzz said so himself, and partly because it really does sound that way.  i love that record.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Joe Deutrom

POTRE is great. Who doesn't like it except maybe the long departed Tony?

Vcavallo

hahah..tony hated it!  what a funny fellow he was.  

hey, TOOL, are you still around these parts?  you're a good guy, i don't recall seeing you post lately.  how's the family?
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

TOOL

Yeah, I'm still around.  I don't post very often but I still love all of my Melvins brothers & sisters.  We're all we've got!
There's a lot of things blamed on me that never happened.  But then, there's a lot of things that I did that I never got caught at.

rhett E rock

POTRE = genious.  one of the craziest albums ever.  'nuff said.

i'd have to disagree.  i think both bands had some similarities before Buzz was even involved with Fantomas.  but that's just my two cents.

AlmightyRetard

Quote from: rhett E rockPOTRE = genious.  one of the craziest albums ever.  'nuff said.

i'd have to disagree.  i think both bands had some similarities before Buzz was even involved with Fantomas.  but that's just my two cents.

Didn't Buzz "invent" Fant
I like fucking corpses

cellphone


Vcavallo

haha, good call cellphone....

from what i've heard, Patton wrote a good deal of the songs as demos and played all the instruments on them (don't know how he pulled off the drums), sending the recordings to the current members as bait to join..  
can anyone back this up?
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

cellphone

no, but he could've just used a drum machine to demo it

rhett E rock

telepathy...it's all telepathy.  that's how he gets it across to his minions so they can play.  we don't even listen to music when we put on a Fantomas CD.  it's Pattons minds tapping into us!!!

blipntime

i dunno man the whole ipecac aesthetic is pretty dull. everything kind of blurs together.

klump

fantomas is pretty much a mix of melvins, slayer, melt banana, ruins ,merzbow and mike patton...

klump

and the melvins were allready using keyboards on stoner witch and stag.

luciano darkage

dig the first 3 tracks on potre, dont really enjoy the rest, that riff that keeps on repeating in pigs irritates me no matter how much i try to like it, last 1/3 of the track starts well but it doesnt go far enough for me, the rest does nothing for me,

i like "what the fuck" harsh noise, it just sounds to well organised and to cleanly produced, i like shit raw .. dirty under produced bedroom recordings, the latter songs are recorded (produced) fucked up and i like the ideas but it it just doesnt move me


but thats just my opinion

how bout yourselves dirty or clean?