If you had to put together a melvins best of.....

Started by Haggardsue, September 15, 2005, 05:21:00 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Haggardsue

So yes, if you were in charge of putting together a best of by the wonderful melvins what tracks would you have on it??? If it had to be limited to say 15 songs (much like melvinmania)  what would be your selections. Here's mine in no particular order

1 Black Stooges
2 Mombius Hibachi
3 Let It All Be
4 amazon (yes i know this is technically two tracks but the magic of editing would come into play)
5 Revolve
6 Boris
7 It's Shoved
8 Night Goat
9 The Bit
10 Oven
11 Easy as it Was
12 Antioxidote
13 With Teeth
14 If I had an exorcism
15 Skin Horse

Feel Free to bicker and complain about my selections.

AlmightyRetard

Wow, that's actually a great list of songs. Mine is kind of the same in some places.

1. The Bit
2. Don't Piece Me
3. Easy As It Was
4. Horn Bearer
5. Jew Boy Flower Head
6. Honey Bucket
7. Little Judas Chongo
8. The Bloated Pope
9. Mombius Hibachi
10. Boris
11. Dead Dressed
12. Anaconda
13. At The Stake
14. Buck Owens
15. Pigs Of The Roman Empire

But this was hard. 25 songs would be easier  :lol:
I like fucking corpses

Chomas

I think the neither here nor there disc hit the nail pretty much on the head

norecess

I hate these kind of lists. Once you've created one, you immediately disagree with it. Nevertheless, it's fun to read other's lists and comment on 'em ;]

Anyway, I'd definitely put Eyeflys, Creepy Smell and  It's Shoved, Zodiac and Excorcism (I love that chain on Bullhead) in it. Annum is also one of my favorites, but it's not really a Melvins song.

Hank Hill

Let it all be
Green Manalishi
Queen
Road Bull
intro
black stooges
little judas chongo
Lysol
the bit
the bloat
up the dumper
with teeth
prig

Lividity

1. Gluey Porch Treatments (Electroretard version)
2. Copache
3. Joan Of Arc
4. Honey Bucket
5. At The Stake
6. Hag Me
7. Lovely Butterflies (Electroretard version)
8. Lizzy
9. Revolve
10. Skweetis
11. Tipping The Lion
12. Shevil

Anyone notice that this is more like a "My Melvins Picks" collection rather than a "Best Of" collection? Oh well. Who cares anyway.

klump

there should be a list of songs they dont play often or dont play at all.

many of the honky songs f.ex

norecess

Quote from: Hank Hill
Lysol
...
with teeth

You mean Roman Bird Dog instead of Lysol, right?

Rembrandt Pussyhorse

No Melvins comp is complete without Charmicarmicat.
I could catch a monkey

Hank Hill

Quote from: norecess
Quote from: Hank Hill
Lysol
...
with teeth

You mean Roman Bird Dog instead of Lysol, right?


Yeah - the "Lysol to get me high" song.  

Hell - at that point in my best of you could play the whole Lysol album.  Although "Sacrifice" and "Dwight Fry" are covers, they atleast get an honorable mention for some of the best Melvins compositions.

AlmightyRetard

Quote from: norecessI hate these kind of lists. Once you've created one, you immediately disagree with it.

Indeed man :lol:
I like fucking corpses

frozenweasel

It's Shoved
Youth Of America
The Fool, The Meddling Idiot
Foaming
Lizzy
Pearl Bomb
Forgotten Principles
Berthas
Tipping The Lion
Revolve
Roadbull
Magic Pig Detective
Toy
Mary Lady Bobby Kins
Judy
We All Love Judy

Leroy

they should put out a cd or double cd with all those songs on the hard to find 7 inches, like anal satan and the "sawed off 7" songs.
kinda like electroretard

TGH

Whenever my friends ask me to make them a Melvins CD; I just burn them Prick or COD.
This isn't a time for lectures!

Chomas

queen should be on there too though, and most of pigs of the roman empire