Melvins mentioned in new york times.

Started by groundmeat, September 17, 2005, 02:36:03 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

groundmeat

Melvins get credited as one of the originators of the "avant-metal" music that have become "popular" these days Mastodon, Isis, Orthrelm gets mentioend!

Here is the link (free reg. required).

http://www.nytimes.com/2005/09/18/arts/music/18cara.html?pagewanted=1&adxnnl=0&8hpib&adxnnlx=1126984986-4rrg+qWQSRmUJGheVnMAVg////

groundmeat

And here is the text.

If the mods think this is going to get this site in trouble (copyright or whatever) please delete this.

Heavy Metal Gets an M.F.A.

By JON CARAMANICA
Published: September 18, 2005 in NY Times

YOU might not have known it from looking at the audience, but when the Chicago instrumental band Pelican performed at the Knitting Factory in late July, it was playing metal.

Instead of long hair and all-black outfits, the crowd was displaying the trappings of brainy, slightly nerdy indie rock. Young men wore artistically cropped hair and tight-legged jeans, and there was even a smattering of young women in librarian glasses and worn-out Chuck Taylor sneakers.

This is not your older brother's metal crowd. "I've been wearing my Def Leppard T-shirt on tour recently," said Laurent Lebec, a guitarist in Pelican and a fan of that archteypal 1980's metal band. "People come up to me and ask, 'Is that a joke?' I have to tell them that I don't wear T-shirts as a joke."

The particularly dark and aggressive strain of rock called heavy metal has been around for more than three decades. In that time, it has spawned a range of offshoots, but none have been as unlikely as the recent wave of bands using metal as a jumping-off point for a range of experimental styles, dabbling in free jazz, minimalist post-rock, noise and even modern classical music.

This is art-metal, a curious scene populated by a new generation of metal acolytes onstage and younger fans often unfamiliar with metal's headbanger heritage.

"Metal in general has long been unjustly maligned as solely the province of knuckle-dragging meatheads," said Aaron Turner, a founder of the influential Hydra Head Records, which has released three CD's by Pelican, including, recently, "The Fire in Our Throats Will Beckon the Thaw." "That said, there's never been a group of musicians like there is now, who are helping to advance the form."

Heavy metal reached a commercial apex with the hair-metal bands of the 80's, but those spandex-and-lipstick aficionados were often maligned within the greater heavy metal scene. Metal, many argued, should be punishing and morbid, not garish. So while the flashy acts caught on in the pop arena, the metal mainstream focused on technique and form, honing a high degree of technical complexity. By the outset of the 90's, eccentrics like the Melvins and the Flying Luttenbachers were acting on the belief that heavy music was compatible with an avant-garde sensibility. Their peers didn't all agree.

"For years, I felt we didn't have any common ground with anyone - I felt like I was on the inside of it, but not always a welcome visitor," said Justin Broadrick, a member of the pioneering experimental metal bands Napalm Death and Godflesh, who this year released an album with his new band, Jesu, on Hydra Head.

A decade later, those early acts have given rise to others. "Those bands laid the groundwork for us," said Mr. Turner, who also plays in the highly digressive post-metal band Isis. "We're part of a recognizable lineage."

It has produced a scene as noteworthy for its traditional aggression, power and growling guitars as for its appetite for experimentation.

Orthrelm, described by its founder, Mick Barr, as making classically influenced jazz-metal fusion, has just released "OV" (Ipecac), a one-song, 45-minute trancelike tour through seismic noise, North African music and guitar riffs that suggest a needle skipping on an early speed-metal record. Four years ago, the band released the fascinating "Asristir Veildrioxe" (Troubleman Unlimited), which was hypnotic in almost the opposite fashion: 99 tracks lasting a collective 12 minutes. These weren't songs, but rather brainy guitar-and-drum outbursts, each one incrementally different from the others. Mr. Barr called it "the alphabet record, and on our later records, we would use those letters to make longer songs."

Just as influenced by metal, but in wholly different fashion, is Sunn 0))), which borrowed its odd-looking name from the logo of a well-regarded amplifier company. "We take the atmosphere of metal - the barbarism, the unrelentingness - and we apply it to getting the room actually vibrating," said Stephen O'Malley, who also plays with the scabrous and pensive band Khanate. Accordingly, the band's songs, as heard on the slow burn of the forthcoming "Black One" and the just reissued "GrimmRobe Demos," are vast seas of gurgle and drone.

On records, the band haunts. In concert, its members, who perform in druid-style robes and typically use industrial smoke machines, actually alter the feel of the room.

"In that way, the entire space becomes the performance," Mr. O'Malley said.


Greg Anderson, a member of Sunn 0))) and, with Mr. O'Malley, a founder of Southern Lord Records, which releases Sunn 0)))'s albums and has become one of the scene's key labels, argued: "A punk rock ethic has been injected into the metal scene. There's far more room for what we do now, which is good, because what we do wouldn't fly on more traditional metal labels."

Perhaps more than any genre, metal has historically been exceedingly tribal. "When I was growing up, you wore bands' names on the back of your jacket," Mr. Broadrick said. "You would die for them." Throughout the 90's, fierce battle lines were drawn between the metal styles - doom metal, black metal, death metal - that were generally indistinguishable to an uninformed outsider.

But thanks to generational shifts, the current wave of metal experimenters has been less burdened by scene loyalties. "These are people who probably grew up being into metal, but also were into or played in post-rock bands in the 90's, and have finally reconciled the fact that you could fit those two things together," said Andee Connors, co-owner of Aquarius Records in San Francisco, a retail store that specializes in metal.

For a time, as if to drive home its conscientious-objector status, Hydra Head even used the slogan "Thinking Man's Metal."

"It was self-deprecating, but it also exemplified what we wanted to do," Mr. Turner said.

Albert Mudrian, editor of the year-old metal magazine Decibel and author of "Choosing Death: The Improbable History of Death Metal and Grindcore," asks: "Is art conscious or unconscious? Up until now, there was art in metal, but there wasn't for the most part a self-awareness about it. Now, these new artists have that, and they want to be painted as such."

Case in point: When Atsuo, the single-named singer-drummer for the sludgy Japanese post-metal band Boris, was asked recently in the online magazine radcompany.net about the influence of Satan on the band's work, he gave a predictably high-minded answer, engaging the question's absurdity - heavy metal's Satanic influenceis one of the genre's great clich

Joe Deutrom

Quoteworn-out Chuck Taylor sneakers.

Pretty soon it will be Melvins Nike's. Hey maybe all this "heavy music" will resurrect RIP magazine.

Galvano

To me, Mastodon is just another metalband.
I like Isis, but have no idea why they would be mentioned in the same article as the Melvins, I find no similarities at all.
In fact I'm getting pretty tired of all these bands that are namedropping the Melvins in interviews, just hoping to share the same shelf in record stores.

norecess

Quote from: GalvanoTo me, Mastodon is just another metalband.

Wow, that's kind of shocking really. What other recent metal bands do you consider average?

Galvano

You tell me, I don't listen to recent metal a whole lot.
And why do you find that shocking?

norecess

Quote from: GalvanoYou tell me, I don't listen to recent metal a whole lot.

That explains it.

QuoteAnd why do you find that shocking?

'Cause they're one of the best bands around. I'm curious what their Warner release will be like.

norecess

Just finished reading the entire article, so that's why I post this second response.

Quote from: GalvanoI like Isis, but have no idea why they would be mentioned in the same article as the Melvins, I find no similarities at all.
The article is about a change in heavy metal which has taken place in the last years - or maybe already in the 90s, as the article suggest by mentioning bands like the Melvins and Godflesh. And you cannot deny that there's a metal influence in both Isis and Melvins. The subject is much wider than Isis and the Melvins.

QuoteIn fact I'm getting pretty tired of all these bands that are namedropping the Melvins in interviews, just hoping to share the same shelf in record stores.
Don't be so negative, I bet you haven't even read the article carefully. No one is namedropping. It's the author who is mentioning the Melvins, and just once. The Melvins aren't even a big part of the article.

And what's wrong with a little namedropping now and then. As long as bands like Mastodon and Isis do the namedropping, I'm fine with it. Even if a band like Limp Dick Shit would have mentioned the Melvins, it would be funny. Besides, nu-metal kids would never like the Melvins. They would download 2 or 3 tunes and then hate the band for the rest of their life.

Galvano

Quote from: norecessJust finished reading the entire article, so that's why I post this second response.

The article is about a change in heavy metal which has taken place in the last years - or maybe already in the 90s, as the article suggest by mentioning bands like the Melvins and Godflesh. And you cannot deny that there's a metal influence in both Isis and Melvins. The subject is much wider than Isis and the Melvins.

I'm not sure I understand you correctly, yes there is "metal" in both Isis and Melvins, but if you weren't so hung up genres you'd see what I'm talking about. There's also "metal" in Limp Bizkit, do you suggest Melvins and Limp Bizkit share the same soundpicture and style?
I'm talking about the music, to me Isis and Melvins have nothing in common musically except possibly the idea of creating an atmosphere for the listener.


Quote from: norecessDon't be so negative, I bet you haven't even read the article carefully. No one is namedropping. It's the author who is mentioning the Melvins, and just once. The Melvins aren't even a big part of the article.

First off, don't tell me how to be, that's just dumb, you don't know me.
Second, clearly I wrote "in interviews". This is not an interview alas I was not talking about this particular article.

Quote from: norecessAnd what's wrong with a little namedropping now and then. As long as bands like Mastodon and Isis do the namedropping, I'm fine with it. Even if a band like Limp Dick Shit would have mentioned the Melvins, it would be funny. Besides, nu-metal kids would never like the Melvins. They would download 2 or 3 tunes and then hate the band for the rest of their life.

Namedropping...
It just seem to me like there's a lot of it going on right now, and especially Melvins's name. All of a sudden Melvins is every rockband's biggest influence

Galvano

Quote from: norecess
That explains it.

That explains what?
I've heard their tunes, I've seen them live, they didn't move me.

norecess

Quote from: Galvano
Quote from: norecessThat explains it.
That explains what?.
Your previous comment on Mastodon.

norecess

Quote from: Galvano
Quote from: norecess
The article is about a change in heavy metal which has taken place in the last years - or maybe already in the 90s, as the article suggest by mentioning bands like the Melvins and Godflesh. And you cannot deny that there's a metal influence in both Isis and Melvins. The subject is much wider than Isis and the Melvins.
I'm not sure I understand you correctly, yes there is "metal" in both Isis and Melvins, but if you weren't so hung up genres you'd see what I'm talking about.

I'm not talking about genres, am I?

QuoteI'm talking about the music, to me Isis and Melvins have nothing in common musically except possibly the idea of creating an atmosphere for the listener.

And that's exactly what I'm talking about. I'm interested in music, rather than focusing on one genre. I don't even care care about the genre, as long as the music is innovative, open minded, experimental and able to feed my soul.

Quote
Quote from: norecessDon't be so negative, I bet you haven't even read the article carefully. No one is namedropping. It's the author who is mentioning the Melvins, and just once. The Melvins aren't even a big part of the article.
First off, don't tell me how to be, that's just dumb, you don't know me.

I don't, but what I can do, and will do, is write down how I think you are acting. And that sounded a bit negative to me. Don't be offended so easily.  It almost seems that you wanna beat me up for fucks sake.

QuoteSecond, clearly I wrote "in interviews". This is not an interview alas I was not talking about this particular article.

OK, clear.

QuoteIt just seem to me like there's a lot of it going on right now, and especially Melvins's name. All of a sudden Melvins is every rockband's biggest influence

I know what you mean. I have it all the time. Aas soon as I discover a band I haven't heard of before, it seems that all of a sudden everyone else knows 'em too. But that's nonsense. It just seems that way.

Wow, I'm actually proud of this post. It's quoted so well, and that on a 14" monitor with a screen resolution of 1024x768.

groundmeat

I thought the article was interetsting because it pointed out two things.

The first is that the apparent change in audience - from the sterotypical big hairy knuckledraggers to the more nerdy type. I don't think this is completely accurate because metal (or at least good metal) always attracted people interested in technical music, which means you have to have at least some basic level of thoughtfulness. The knuckledragger image was probably perpetuated by fans of hair/frat-metal of the 80's. But I wasn't into music at all around that time so I can't say.

The second thing the article points out, which I think is correct, is that the emphasis in metal music is moving away  from stuff that requires "mere" monkey power (solos etc.) to stuff that requires creativity or compositional skills. And this is what the melvins etc. focused on. And the current crop of popular metal bands like Mastodon, Isis, DEP are also more focused on composing interesting music rather than showing off their mad guitar skillz.

duster

i think isis is pretty overrated. the vocals are embarrassing, as well. i still like them, they just get too much credit

Galvano

Quote from: norecess
I know what you mean. I have it all the time. Aas soon as I discover a band I haven't heard of before, it seems that all of a sudden everyone else knows 'em too. But that's nonsense. It just seems that way.

Oh I don't take it personally, I just think it's a cheap shot at trying to gain cred.