Stag Vs Hostile Ambient Takeover

Started by Joe Deutrom, May 24, 2006, 02:20:35 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Out of these two which one has the edge?

Stag
19 (43.2%)
H.A.T.
25 (56.8%)

Total Members Voted: 33

Ministry Fiend

Definately Stag! H.A.T is awesome.....................but Stag is special :cheers:

Joe Deutrom

I definitely planned this poll to be difficult. I did the Ozma VS Bullhead more an a whim but later I realized that a lot of the older members here think very highly of Bullhead and I find it interesting reading people's opinions when you are comparing Melvins with Melvins. Maybe more polls will come like Honky Vs Eggnog. Or Houdini Vs Gluey Porch Treaments.

didlisquat

H.A.T. has slowly come to be one of my favorites.
Stag has alot of kick ass tracks, no doubt.
H.A.T. has a better flow to it.
when man's only distant relative
has descended on his own
you will know

Andy

HAT definitely has a better flow and doesn't have a single bad second. Also bonus points have to be given for the Rutmanis bass that owns this album. Half the time it sounds like an angry elephant is trying to attack Buzz and Dale or something!
For your health!


Vcavallo

Quote from: Andy on May 25, 2006, 08:29:56 PM
Rutmanis bass....Half the time it sounds like an angry elephant is trying to attack Buzz and Dale or something!


hahaha YES!
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

klump

These are my two TOP favourites, so its a hard pick but I tend to listen to HAT a bit more.
I love the different nuances of Stag , but HAT is so destilled , refined and perfected  :D

But I must add that I like ALL of the albums.
they all have different qualities.

CaptainPungent

I might like HAT a little bit more than Stag.

It's got that same fucking awesome drumming like Bullhead and heaviness.
For that, it's got edge.
also, they have Dr. Geek, a psychobillyish song that fucking rocks.
Little Judas Chongo is perhaps my favorite track on the album.
The guitar has a sound on it that clicks a switch in my brain.

so if edge means heaviness, HAT has won it.
if edge means weirdness, Stag wins it.

klump

Quote from: CaptainPungent on May 26, 2006, 12:38:09 PM
I might like HAT a little bit more than Stag.

It's got that same fucking awesome drumming like Bullhead and heaviness.
For that, it's got edge.
also, they have Dr. Geek, a psychobillyish song that fucking rocks.
Little Judas Chongo is perhaps my favorite track on the album.
The guitar has a sound on it that clicks a switch in my brain.

so if edge means heaviness, HAT has won it.
if edge means weirdness, Stag wins it.

yeah, but they are both weird.
but I think its sort of a silly task to put Melvins records up against each other...its IMPOSSIBLE.

Lunica

i don't have a square to spare. can't spare a square.


Joe Deutrom

Stag has some awesome drumming too.  Dale flails toward the of Tipping The Lion.

Metalhead Cow

This is a hard one... I don't know

Mad Arab

I do think HAT has the edge but something about Stag keeps it real close to my heart.

GrimReaper


They both are great records but if you break out Anti-vermin Seed and compare it to Skin Horse, Stag comes out as the best.

The out takes from the Stag recordings that are featured on Singles 1-12 are great songs too.

I broke out this old thread to discuss what Buzz said in one of his e-mail inteviews: there is no more unreleased material.

I guess we got the last of it on 26 Songs, GPT Re-release and Mangled Demos.

:(

Vcavallo

maybe it's true, but i don't believe anything he says.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo