pigs of the roman empire reviews thread

Started by benton netty, August 30, 2004, 08:55:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.

benton netty

hey, i thought i'd start a thread where reviews of the "pigs" album could be deposited.

i found one that eerily articulates the same exact problems that i have with the album...here's a quote:

"Lustmord

idiotboy

interesting review - i agree with this review too - especially:

'The problem is simple. It

Galvano

The first 6 minutes of the title song sounds (to me)  like a background sound to a computer game.

Chomas

the new album is amazing, maybe their best really.  You guys just have ADD and that's the main problem.  The depth of the album I think is completely bewildering, and awe inspiring.

benton netty

Quote from: change&suffocationthe new album is amazing, maybe their best really.  You guys just have ADD and that's the main problem.  The depth of the album I think is completely bewildering, and awe inspiring.

while i agree with you about a lot of the people here having ADD, i can assure you that i'm not afflicted, myself. look at my ridiculously long posts for proof.

i'm interested in what you have to say, though -- explain what exactly is so "deep" and "awe inspiring" about the album, if you would. because i totally think that it is doing nothing but pretending to be those things.

(PAUL)

Quote from: GalvanoThe first 6 minutes of the title song sounds (to me)  like a background sound to a computer game.

I was thinking the same thing, like it would fit perfectly with Doom 3. Here's the review from All Music Guide, which gave it a three out of five:

This time out, the Melvins have tapped noise and mood specialist Lustmord, and his presence is felt right from the beginning. Drawing a death's-head card from Lustmord solo efforts like 2000's Purifying Fire, Pigs of the Roman Empire begins with the creepy, crawly "III." Ambient bumps in the night punctuate the severe bottom end as a hissing waver builds with horribly steady precision -- it's like being caught in a bear trap as the machete-wielding maniac trudges closer and closer. The eventual "Bloated Pope" is much more the Melvins', er, speed. Though it's grounded in whip-smart rhythmic clarity and includes a soupy fog breakdown, it's still a choking, stuttering gigantor headed by a classicist King Buzzo vocal ("Insect from the crawling Mother!") and squalid wails of electric guitar. (Tool's Adam Jones is again part of the proceedings for Pigs.) The title track is a straight duet of Melvins' slime and Lustmord spook. It begins as an exercise in the latter's penchant for moody gloom. The fearsome, buttressed trickling space he builds suggests train stations surrendered to neglect, and knights in black satin. But that early passage gradually gives ground to a deliberate, tonal guitar solo, which is then swallowed by more dead starship moaning. This interplay continues throughout the track's latter half -- since it pushes past the twenty-minute mark, there's plenty of time to match the distortion sludge to cavernous spatial howling. Still, as arresting as Lustmord's soundscapes are, Pigs of the Roman Empire could've been louder. While the pounding stoner psychoses of "Pink Bat" and "Safety Third" are strong and great, their energy is sucked mightily into collapsed Lustmordian stars like "Idolatrous Apostate," or the untitled hidden track. The solution is probably to look at Pigs as an exploratory effort along the lines of Sunn 0))), whose own path led from churning metal freakery to haunting middle-earth alchemy. Either that, or the Melvins have given us a batch of field recordings made on the River Styx's wharf.
Hail, not fail.
PS:  fuck him.

Chomas

I read the review and obviously the reviewer is looking for the melvins to release another bullhead, which is retarded.  I personally think the album is rather cohesive, and yet I like that it is probably more abstract (maybe not though) than HAT.  I enjoy Lustmords input, and think it makes for an interestingly different album.  

From the review:
"The problem is simple. It

Chomas

oh yeah I forgot to mention the title track KICKS ABSOLUTE FUCKING ASS!!!!

benton netty

Quote from: change&suffocationI read the review and obviously the reviewer is looking for the melvins to release another bullhead

i don't think that's necessarily true, at all. just because you see a band's strengths as being a particular thing doesn't mean that you need them to regurgitate that thing. me, i love the melvins for their diversity. but i think this album is weak, too.

i don't know, i'm sure there were plenty of people who defended michael jordan's detour into playing baseball for a while, and they accused of all that thought he should stick to basketball of being unable to let him do what he wanted, or whatever.

another bullhead? i don't want that. but do i want the melvins to write interesting rock songs? yes. this album lacks that.

Quotewhich is retarded.  I personally think the album is rather cohesive, and yet I like that it is probably more abstract (maybe not though) than HAT.

i think that this album, on the abstraction scale, makes HAT look like a ramones album. HAT, to me, was the melvins continuing to morph as a rock band, and it proved that they could still come up with amazing compositions, almost 20 years into their career.

QuoteI enjoy Lustmords input, and think it makes for an interestingly different album.

From the review:
"The problem is simple. It

anaconda

"... (Bloated Pope) is a choking, stuttering gigantor headed by a classicist King Buzzo vocal ("Insect from the crawling Mother!") and squalid wails..."

that part is kick ass and true!!! best song on here , i also like safety third alot. the title track is truly epic. but anyway, alot of it has me reaching for ffwd.

regarding suffo's comment about Bullhead, i was going to say this the
other day but i was afraid of being flamed to death!! ;

"I can't wait for Bullhead 2005, lets hope they write it! haha"

Pringles

The title song kick ass, specially at the end tne second half (12 minute).
One of the darkest Melvins song since Air breather of Honky.
Luck is a residue of design

anaconda

it would almost be a better honky if it had two more
"real" songs and a few less lustmord bits, still after all is said and
done i'm happy on the most part. especially after that saved message/thank you bullshit release before this.. . i got nervous
for a bit there that god's band the melvins gave up real songs!

phew!!

klump

i didnt read the review before...

who gives a fuck?!

they could write that the cd is an anal probe and try to make me shove it up my ass but i wouldnt do it...

and dammit, where is all the humor tolerance we had here before?

anaconda

klump baby, i'm being as funny as i can man, i hear you though.
shit's done changed around here! its not the crew anymore, its alot
of newbs and intolerators, but diversity is healthy man! PM me bro.

steve

After a few listens; I like it...

Sure, I doubt "Pigs" will go down as one of my top-5 Melvins album but like all Melvins CDs I can listen to the whole thing without skipping tracks or fast forwarding (well, except Prick...) - something I cannot say for most CDs produced by other bands. And that lullaby bit right at the end keeps going through my head...

It would be nice, though, if a lot of the music was not given that "cheap boombox" effect.

Still... the actual music here is so good I cannot wait for "Never Breathe What You Cannot See" which I am sure will rock... remember that we get two Melvins releases this year... one experimental and one (I hope) of pure music.  :)
...Steve