Vinyl or CD?

Started by Herr Honky, March 25, 2005, 02:47:42 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Herr Honky

First off, i've finally become obsessed enough with the Melvins to actually register here, so a big hello to everyone. About a year ago a friend of mine gave me Stoner Witch, Houdini, and Gluey Porch Treatments. Stoner Witch had me hooked right away, it took me a while to appreciate the greatness of Houdini, and i'm still getting acquainted with GPT. I discovered the band had a mammoth discography so I devoured it all.  Now I just have to start buying them...

Which brings me to my question, should I buy CDs or LPs?  I don't have a record player yet, but i've been planning on starting a record collection for some time now. How easily are Melvins LPs acquired?

Reverend Ebeneezer

Hello there. Depends how much you want to spend on the LPs as I'm pretty sure I'm right in thinking they're all out of rpint, but do turn up on eBay and at record fairs etc. quite regularly at hugely inflated prices. The CDs you can buy from anywhere.

As for quality, I couldn't say. The only Melvins album I own on LP is the Joe Preston solo EP which sounds lovely but I won't go saying that you haven't heard it until you've heard the vinyl...
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

Dog Tired

IF the vinyl is reasonable get it.  Vinyl is super great.

the bloat

Welcome new comer. I would say the greatest downfall of vinyl as opposed to Cd is the convenience. I mean, it's cool to have a giant copy of Honky sittin' in your livingroom, but what the fuck can you do with it besides throw it on the turntable once in a while? What if you want to listen to it in your car or discman? They are great to look at, but the sound quality is NO different because they weren't recorded in analog. It's different when your throwing on a Hendrix record or something because it was meant to be played in that format.

Basically go get the vinyl that you can't get on CD. (7"s, singles, stuff like that) Now, if you find a copy of Alive at the Fucker Club on vinyl....buy that shit!!!!!

chrisandre

You should get it on vinyl, no doubt about it. Vinyl is greater in all ways. The only thing is that you can

Herr Honky

My reasoning for wanting to start a vinyl collection is that it's more permanent and archival. I wouldn't just buy any old album on LP, I would only get my personal favorites. No matter how well I keep them, my CDs always seem to get scratched, and I guess CDs actually start to deteriorate after a decade or so.

About listening to it in a car/discman; one of my ideas is to buy a turntable and hook it up to my computer using a RCA to 1/8" convertor which would allow me to rip it and burn CDs. I think for that to work the turntable would have to have a built-in preamp, but i'm not too sure as I don't know that much stuff about record players yet. Maybe someone could clear this up for me?

Dog Tired

I should put a record player in my car.

anaconda

just run a line-out from the headphone jack on your record player herr.

mumu

Aren't there a lot of skinheads in Fargo?
It's all fucking good-dini as far as I'm concerned. Then again, I'd eat a MELVINS deep fried turd. GO MELVINS!!

-Smellis[/i]

Herr Honky

heh, how the hell would I know.  I just moved here from Bismarck about 8 months ago for school and I don't go out much (bars, etc...) so I have no clue. Where have you heard this?  Even if there was skinheads here, they are probably nothing more than moronic hillbilly tweakers who are looking for a fight.

Do most record players have headphone jacks? I was looking at some on ebay and it didn't look like they did, just RCA outputs. I think I would buy one locally first though, before I got one online

klump

I like sitting on the train and listening to a really good record and just closing my eyes and float away.

but its really nice to just lay down on a good couch and listen to records to.

Dog Tired

Quote from: Herr Honkyheh, how the hell would I know.  I just moved here from Bismarck about 8 months ago for school and I don't go out much (bars, etc...) so I have no clue. Where have you heard this?  Even if there was skinheads here, they are probably nothing more than moronic hillbilly tweakers who are looking for a fight.

Do most record players have headphone jacks? I was looking at some on ebay and it didn't look like they did, just RCA outputs. I think I would buy one locally first though, before I got one online

Well most record players don't have built in speakers....

I have an Aiwa and I have to connect it into my old boom box for sound, and I can just plug in my headsets into there and that's how I listen to records on headsets.

irezumi

You will at least need a pre-amp, but will be better off in the long run with a reciever & speakers(you really will appreciate the type of sound you get that way)... You can get a preamp/mixer pretty cheap if you look around on ebay, take a look at this one:http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=14986&item=7310066645&rd=1

With that in mind, also consider a external sound card to go through a USB port instead of using the stereo-type jack on most line-in ports on most computers..

Take a look at this page & it may answer a few questions and might point out a few things that will help your decision on what to use

http://zisman.ca/Recording/printer_Mac.html

Herr Honky

thanks for the advice. Now i just gotta save up some cash. A guy at a local vinyl shop said he can sell me a turntable for around $60-80, and a whole package (turntable, receiver, speakers) for something like $275. That sound reasonable?

While i was there I also found a copy of Thrones Sperm Whale, kinda surprised me. Hopefully it'll still be there when I get around to getting the system.

I think my first melvins purchases will be Houdini, Stag, or The Bootlicker. Can you only get The Booklicker lp in the trilogy set? I guess I wouldn't mind, The Maggot kicks ass but I could care less about The Crybaby.  Was Eggnog ever released on vinyl?

anaconda

there's Eggnog on vinyl out there. Yessir.