Bring Back Matt Lukin for One Time!

[Captain CoryCory]

Wasn't there something recently stating Lukin retired from music a few years back?

STATEMENT VOID. THREAD OVER. 

[anaconda]

and i heard he's gay. gay people suck!

[Uncle Fester]

oh no,
hes gay!? really?!
I guess I'll go burn my gluey porch vinyl now.
and then Ill fist some sheep.
right, brooklyn?

[anaconda]

 

[Uncle Fester]

I don't think Matt sucks,

Thats right! You KNOW he sucks.

How? What is it that you're going after? I'm not denying you your opinion on his playing - it's just that you haven't mentioned it. You've just said that he sucks. Do you honestly listen to 26 Songs or Gluey Porch Treamtments and think, "the bass player sucks"? If so, why?

nobody cares, but for conversations sake.....
when someone says a bass player sucks I would imagine they are talking about his or her playing abilities. I dont care if matt lukin is a nice guy or a total asshole or if he literally sucks the cock.
while I listen tothe bass in 26 songs and gluey porch treatments I think "this bass player is just playing what he's told to play".  those two albums are all about buzz and dale in my opinion.
thanks for reading, Mints.

[Mints]

while I listen tothe bass in 26 songs and gluey porch treatments I think "this bass player is just playing what he's told to play".  those two albums are all about buzz and dale in my opinion.

There you go. You finally said something. It follows that you feel the same way about every album that came before Prick.

[Uncle Fester]

while I listen tothe bass in 26 songs and gluey porch treatments I think "this bass player is just playing what he's told to play".  those two albums are all about buzz and dale in my opinion.

There you go. You finally said something. It follows that you feel the same way about every album that came before Prick.

did YOU just tell ME how I feel about every melvins album before prick?

boy, mints... you're really something.

[Mints]

while I listen tothe bass in 26 songs and gluey porch treatments I think "this bass player is just playing what he's told to play".  those two albums are all about buzz and dale in my opinion.

There you go. You finally said something. It follows that you feel the same way about every album that came before Prick.

did YOU just tell ME how I feel about every melvins album before prick?

Nope. YOU just told ME. Read above. Use your good eye.

[Uncle Fester]

did someone just say something?

[Mints]

You said, while I listen tothe bass in 26 songs and gluey porch treatments I think "this bass player is just playing what he's told to play".  That describes every bass player up to Mark, so it follows that you would feel the same way about them as you do about Matt. It's okay for me to say that.

[moose]

Hey! I think the guy who started this thread was just fucking kidding. Obviously it won't happen. All the serious debate and fighting is funny though...

[SeattleSam]

Hey! I think the guy who started this thread was just fucking kidding. Obviously it won't happen. All the serious debate and fighting is funny though...

It will happen if you just believe!

[Uncle Fester]

You said, while I listen tothe bass in 26 songs and gluey porch treatments I think "this bass player is just playing what he's told to play".  That describes every bass player up to Mark, so it follows that you would feel the same way about them as you do about Matt. It's okay for me to say that.

I think I heard something... nah. must have been the wind.

MATT LUKIN IS THE FUCKING BEST! HE SHOULD PLAY ONE MORE SHOW WITH THE MELVINS

-petition signed.

[SeattleSam]

Finally the truth has been acknowledged.

[Mints]

You said, while I listen tothe bass in 26 songs and gluey porch treatments I think "this bass player is just playing what he's told to play".  That describes every bass player up to Mark, so it follows that you would feel the same way about them as you do about Matt. It's okay for me to say that.

I think I heard something... nah. must have been the wind.

MATT LUKIN IS THE FUCKING BEST! HE SHOULD PLAY ONE MORE SHOW WITH THE MELVINS

-petition signed.

You're very defensive. The point you're responding to isn't one that I made. Again, Matt playing with the Melvins isn't the issue I addressed. You're ignoring the fact that Lori and Joe played what they were told to, just like Matt. If you like their sound better just say so. If you like their clothes better just say so. Anything would be better than trying to burn me for asking an honest question.