i had to start this..

[black stallion]

we've just seen Melvins doing some amazing performances with Dunn as trio. plus we've seen ( from some videos Mr Lucky has posted) BB doing what they do better,rocking,in the most straight forward way!

what if things would stay the way they are now?


share your opinion!

[Shatz]

Maybe the BigBelvins still have some aces up their sleeves. But Buzzo writes most of the songs anyway. And Dale just sounds way more powerful on his own.
Trevor Dunn would be a most welcome addition, bringing a fresh sound to the group.
So to sum it up: I'm all for the change.
(A Dunnvins album of new songs would be a wet dream come true)

[Braykfast]

"(A Dunnvins album of new songs would be a wet dream come true)"

Agreed.

A Melvins/ Lustmord performance is needed first.

[GrimReaper]

I want more Bigmelvins material. But i'm happy with everything. Remeber the suprise of POTRE? How about a Melvins lite tour album? Like the residency box? They played many songs not usualy covered.

[jonE5]

It would be amazing! But highly unlikely.. Ideally it would be great if both versions of the band toured and recorded

[MagusPerde]

Just a vote for BigMelvins. I like Melvins w/Dunn, but I love the 4 man Melvins.  In my opinion, the Melvins have released three straight great studio albums with BB. "Civilized Worm" is one of the best rock songs of the last decade.  I like it this way: BIGMELVINS as the main dish and DunnMelvins as a side dish.



"Least of dolls, it goes unspoken, you should have known"

[ManWithNoName]

I don't care either way but I do hope to see some more Dunn action because he is the fucking man.

[Idlehanz]

I'm tired of the whole argument really.  I love em either way.   Whatever will be, will be.

[FartLips]

Bring on the three piece!

[EvilNewWarGod]

I'm tired of the whole argument really.  I love em either way.   Whatever will be, will be.

I'm with you on this. I don't care which way it goes, just give me more Melvins albums! But goddamn those videos with Dunn are impressive as hell. Buzzo was right when he referred to him as "stinkingly talented" in the liner notes for History of Gluttony and Lust

[pinkyslim]

i saw Melvins lite.

I would chose Melvins lite over the current line up.

Dales drumming is lighter and no barbershop vocals.

[MrLuck87]

Bring on both line ups!  The more Melvins the better!

[gesundheit]

I want more Bigmelvins material. But i'm happy with everything. Remeber the suprise of POTRE? How about a Melvins lite tour album? Like the residency box? They played many songs not usualy covered.

I would be stoked if Toshi recorded the Melvins lite tour!!!

[(the) Razor]

I like my Melvins lite. Would prefer to hear Dale just drum and Buzzo just on vocals and X just on bass. Far more interesting.

[black stallion]

I'm tired of the whole argument really.  I love em either way.   Whatever will be, will be.

But goddamn those videos with Dunn are impressive as hell.

The Melvins (Lite) at the Detroit Bar