THOUGHTS:
I was not that into this album when it came out but I was not yet a fanatic.
Now I see its genius. While "A History of Bad Men" and "Civilized Worm" are probably the most representative songs on the record it's "A History of Drunks" and "A Vast Filthy Prison" and "Blood Witch" and "You've Never Been Right" that I find myself anticipating the most.
But talking about the songs is far less interesting than talking about the album as a whole. I just listened to "Pet Sounds" the other day. I dare say Buzz is the Brian Wilson of the electric age.
Jared's voice has a greater range especially in the high registers which allows Buzz to write songs he simply wouldn't have been able to perform earlier (think of how hard he was reaching in "Hog Leg"). In context it's amazing for the primary songwriter and singer in a band to suddenly put himself in the backseat on half the album just because the new bass player can hit a high note. It is proof to me that Buzz has the utmost respect for his records and that his ethos is true.
Secondly this album stands as a landmark now (with three and a half albums worth of continuing proof) that those drum parts Dale has been playing were never random. When you listen to Bullhead for example it is easy enough to fall into the trap of convincing yourself that the wool is being pulled over the listener's eyes and ears. But when you hear Coady and Dale sync up so tightly on pretty much everything they play it sheds the light of deliberate intention on the 25 albums of Dale's drums previous.
I love this record, and its continuation in Nude, Bride, and Bulls. In that it is an experiment in band dynamics has probably made the record one of the least experimental in terms of avant garde approaches (my first listen I probably dismissed it as a classic rock nostalgia album). But there are literally dozens of classic Melvins riffs throughout. The difference is that the songs are not relying on the riffage, rather showcasing them at the appropriate time.
Also the FBI warning on the CD label is amazing.