If you had to put together a melvins worst of ...

[Hog log]

Spread Eagle Beagle
Pointless

i'd say meaningless for the non-drummers

[rhett E rock]

Prick.  i think Hog Log said it.  i like the album though...probably their worst release if i had a gun pointed to my head and had to choose. 

all these Crybaby haters, i can't believe that.  it's not a true Melvins release, but it's a valid album by all means.  it's a fun record.

[Lunica]

exactly.
i think the leif garret song is hilarious. and GI joe.. its not the best patton song, but it is patton.
and i thought the big band cd was great, its nice to hear other variations of the songs, although they're great in their original shapes as well. i know we got a lot of patton haters here, but im not one of them 

[DubEMC]

I didn't read the whole thread but how many people said " Set Me Straight "?

I think I'm the only person who likes that song.

[GrimReaper]

Pigtro

Spread Eagle (no Beagle from 1-12)

1-12 Queen version.

I know you can explain these away as B-sides of the 1-12 Singles, but they suck.

Fuck I love Queen on Stoner but this 1-12 version is just plain anoying, you want to rock out and your ass is stiffled.

Reverand Eb have hatted Crybaby forever. But here's how I look at it: I got into Hank III, Skeleton Key and Blood Bliss because of this release. And I like it.

Who said they hate Stoner Witch? That is fucken blaspheme.

"How About"  off Prick does anyone ever listen to this?

Theresa Screams, Skitter and Digital Silence plus the 26 Songs lawn mower recording I don't consider songs.

Thank You Saved Message just an E-bay profit maker, who can hate that?

So I guess these are my only dreaded Melvins tunes:

Pigtro

Spread Eagle (no Beagle from 1-12)

1-12 Queen version.

How About (Prick)

[Anonymous]

If I Had An Exorcism.

[rhett E rock]

I didn't read the whole thread but how many people said " Set Me Straight "?

I think I'm the only person who likes that song.

i love that song, especially the track after that as well.

[Anonymous]

I used to like that song.

Until I learnt how to play it.

Now I no longer enjoy listening to it.

I'm not sure how that works. 

[Reverend Ebeneezer]

Another one for consideration...

Kool Legged.

Now, I know I've already bashed Ozma once this thread but even so I really hate this song...I've never heard a version of it that sounds good. I thought that having Joe Preston chime in on it on 'Salad...' might've made it better but, no, it still does nothing for me.

And yeah, I know I come off as very negative about The Crybaby but let me make myself clear. Some of it, I quite like. The Hank Williams III tracks, f'rinstance and the version of Teen Spirit makes me smile but so much of it just leaves me cold...Generally speaking I don't think I'm one for the Melvins collaborating on anything much. I like 'Pigs...' but even the Melvana thing doesn't really flip my switch.

[rhett E rock]

Reverand Eb have hatted Crybaby forever. But here's how I look at it: I got into Hank III, Skeleton Key and Blood Bliss because of this release. And I like it.

yeah that album got me into Hank III.  Bliss Blood they're a band i've kept meaning to get into, but haven't yet, as well as Skeleton Key.  that song Bliss Blood does is INSANE on the Crybaby.  do these bands sound as good as they do on that album?

[klump]

Reverand Eb have hatted Crybaby forever. But here's how I look at it: I got into Hank III, Skeleton Key and Blood Bliss because of this release. And I like it.

yeah that album got me into Hank III.

[KURDTLUVUR!]

Skeleton Key is a much better live band; I'm not sure if they're still together or not.

[norecess]

and foetus` mine is no disgrace.

One of the most intense songs I've ever heard.

[Hog log]

and foetus` mine is no disgrace.

One of the most intense songs I've ever heard.

agreed

[norecess]

and foetus` mine is no disgrace.

One of the most intense songs I've ever heard.

agreed

It also made me listen to 'that Yes song'.

*Foetus has been added to queue*